Dean wishes for his family back, and John Winchester shows up from 2003. Krissy and Nate count every drink for Supernatural’s 300th episode, “Lebanon.”

Donna’s niece goes missing, a serial killer starts selling body parts to monsters, and Krissy and Nate track every Donna-does-Donna moment along the way.

Dean jumps back to a Nazi-occupied submarine for the Hand of God, while “Castiel” back home is secretly Lucifer—and closing in on Sam. Krissy and Nate break it down.

We crack open Season 12, Episode 2, “Mamma Mia,” where Sam is still a captive of the British Men of Letters while Dean, Mary, and Castiel scramble for a lead on where he’s being held.

We chase down a weapon that can kill Hell’s rising threat, and the guy who has it would really rather be left alone. It’s Supernatural’s Cain classic, First Born.

A haunted B&B, real Lizzie Borden lore, and Sam’s true-crime obsession—Krissy and Nate drink their way through Supernatural’s “Thin Lizzie.”

We cover Season 8, Episode 6, “Southern Comfort,” of Supernatural. When violent deaths hit Kearney, Missouri, Sam and Dean arrive to find a familiar hunter already on the case.

We pour our way through Season 10, Episode 12 of Supernatural, “About a Boy,” a case where a string of disappearances keeps ending the same way: a flash of light and an abandoned hex bag.

We cover Season 9, Episode 7, “Bad Boys”—building a drinking game companion to the Supernatural episode where a mysterious call pulls Dean back to a boys’ ranch in upstate New York.

We dive into Season 9, Episode 6, “Heaven Can’t Wait”—the one where a newly human Castiel is living his best (and most mundane) life working a gas station convenience store.