We pour our way through Season 10, Episode 12 of Supernatural, “About a Boy,” a case where a string of disappearances keeps ending the same way: a flash of light and an abandoned hex bag.

We cover Season 9, Episode 7, “Bad Boys”—building a drinking game companion to the Supernatural episode where a mysterious call pulls Dean back to a boys’ ranch in upstate New York.

We dive into Season 9, Episode 6, “Heaven Can’t Wait”—the one where a newly human Castiel is living his best (and most mundane) life working a gas station convenience store.

We crack open Supernatural Season 7, Episode 4, “Defending Your Life”—the one where Sam and Dean chase a string of mysterious deaths where victims are being punished by their own dark pasts.

We take on Season 8, Episode 18, “Freaks and Geeks”, where Sam and Dean roll into a small town on a vampire case and find a team of teenage hunters already working the same nest.

We dive into Season 6, Episode 21, “Let It Bleed”—a pivotal late-season chapter where the Winchester brothers find themselves tangled in a dangerous web involving H.P. Lovecraft and more.

We dive into Supernatural’s The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo—the beloved introduction of Charlie Bradbury, where the Winchesters need to break into a corporation’s servers.

We tackle Season 5, Episode 19 of Supernatural, “Hammer of the Gods.” Sam and Dean get trapped among a gathering of pagan deities with a very specific agenda for their two famous guests.

We drink and discuss Supernatural season 4, episode 12, “Criss Angel Is a Douchebag,” where three aging magicians discover real magic via tarot cards that leads to deadly consequences

REBROADCAST: We dive into one of Supernatural’s most beloved meta episodes—Season 5, Episode 8, “Changing Channels,” where the Winchesters face off against the Trickster.