*This transcript is produced using transcription software and reviewed for quality. Despite our best efforts, some passages may be incomplete or contain errors due to audio quality or software limitations.*
Matthew
Hello and welcome back to Superhero Ethics. Friends, you knew that as we start to wrap up, we were going to have the current record holder for most appearances on Superhero Ethics. I believe it is coming in at a cool 37 times: Jessica Plummer. And of course, what else would we talk to Jessica Plummer about but Superman and hope? But before we get into that, one of the things Jessica’s also been a part of is a running conversation about how comic book artistry and comic book moviemaking, as art and as film and as story, intersect with comic books and comic movies as an industry and the making of money. And of course, today as we’re recording, we found out that James Gunn, the person who’s been leading DC for the last couple of years, and I think to most people’s minds was taking it in a pretty good direction, one or two misfires, but overall there’s been a lot of hope and a lot of enjoyment, is now out. There are some new people coming in, and apparently this has more to do with the merger that has happened and some changes in the direction, both fiscally and politically, of DC and its parent company. Jessica, tell us what’s going on.
Jessica
Yeah, so as I think anybody following this podcast probably knows, recently the merger between Warner Bros. and Paramount went through, and they are now Skydance. And seemingly one of the first big announcements… I mean, I will say I did see them saying, “Oh yeah, well, we’re going to have to reevaluate.” It was clear that there would be layoffs. I guess I just hadn’t considered James Gunn would be one of the layoffs. But yeah, James Gunn and Peter Safran are out as heading up DC’s movies, and a new guy, who I guess was at Marvel previously, Jeremy Latcham, is taking over. Honestly, I don’t really know anything about him. From what I’ve heard, it’s not great, but time will tell, I guess.
Matthew
Yeah. And one of my first questions is, when did he work at Marvel? Because I think most of us are in agreement that the first eight, ten years of Marvel were pretty damn great, and then things kind of started to go downhill. And I don’t know about you, but my understanding is Gunn wasn’t just in charge, he was basically in charge of DC visual media for the…
Jessica
DCU.
Matthew
…because he was. And he made only a couple of movies. He started off with a new Superman movie, the Supergirl movie, and I think there was one more in there…
Jessica
Well, and he didn’t direct the Supergirl movie. He produced it.
Matthew
It was part of the universe he had crafted, but he only directed Superman. Right, that’s right. And then also part of that universe was Creature Commandos, which I think a lot of people love, myself included, and Lanterns, which we’ll talk about later in the season as we wrap things up, but which has been, with some I think legitimate concerns from people who are hardcore comic fans, mostly quite well received critically, and certainly another good fit into this overall universe they’re building. Do you know if they’re talking about rebooting once again, or if the idea is that they’re going to continue in this universe Gunn created, or what’s going to happen?
Jessica
I don’t think we know. I think anything right now is just speculation. This guy just started the job, and there are plenty of projects that are already either in development or actually being filmed or drawn or what have you. We’ve seen set photos from the Jimmy Olsen show, The People v. Gorilla Grodd, which has that sort of very specific quirkiness that I associate very strongly with James Gunn. So it’ll be interesting to see if that kind of project continues going forward. And we know there’s a Superman movie coming next summer. But beyond that… oh, and they just announced the casting for, at least the lead casting for, Mister Miracle, the animated TV show. So there’s stuff in the works. How far are they going to get before they pull the plug? I don’t know. I mean, they made an entire Batgirl movie and then pulled the plug. So there’s no stage at which I think we can say, well, they have to release it now, based on past behavior.
Matthew
But I would say, I am going to be very comfortable calling out media companies when they’re trying to censor different messages, or when they want to make things more corporate and stuff like that. And most of the time, I will say that’s probably more about the bottom line and what they think is going to sell versus an actual political agenda. Paramount, which basically bought Time Warner here, has been quite explicit about having a political agenda. Paramount is, among other things, CBS, and so 60 Minutes, for example, which is not anything we’re talking about, it’s a straight-up news show, has had a decidedly more right-wing swing, and memos have come out proving that. As part of CBS, Paramount owns Star Trek and all of the resultant Star Trek franchises.
And we know, again, this has been documented, that Star Trek: Starfleet Academy was shut down in part because it was considered far too woke, that they didn’t want that kind of thing, and that they’ve made statements about not wanting the shows to be so political. Gunn is by no means a raging socialist, but he certainly has a pretty leftist, woke perspective in a lot of the stuff he brings, I would say echoing the comic properties he’s watching. I haven’t looked into it enough, but it seems pretty likely to me that some of that is a part of this move. Have they said anything explicitly about that, or do you know anything about that?
Jessica
I mean, I’ve seen a lot of speculation about exactly that, and I wouldn’t be surprised if that were true. I also wouldn’t be surprised if all these decisions were made before last Tuesday. Well, perhaps. Perhaps they thought the midterms would go a different way than they did. And I’m very sorry that this merger went through under the current government that we have, because it is a monopoly. But yeah, I think that’s the fear. And like you said, James Gunn is not some raging anarchist, right? But he has the ability to parse the source material accurately for the messages of literal social justice that it is communicating, and to put those on the big screen in a way that is really compelling. And if that’s a bridge too far, God only knows what we’re about to get.
Matthew
Yeah. And I would say that he has the ability to not only connect it to general, universalized ideas of social justice, but to the very legit questions of the moment. Like the language that Nicholas Hoult’s Lex Luthor used about Superman being an immigrant, mirroring a lot of the language of our own world, not coincidental. Them fighting an enemy that is very clearly, I referred to as “Netanputin,” an…
Jessica
Amalgam of…
Matthew
…Netanyahu and Putin, with the victims being a kind of mashup of Ukrainians and Gazans. I think, not coincidence. Supergirl is always going to be about feminist themes, and in this recent movie, we may not have loved the execution of it, but the points it was trying to make I think were very legitimate and were directly pulled from modern-day headlines, as I think has often been the case with these heroes themselves. So yeah, we will watch that closely. I think there’s some concern. And I’ve really liked the universe so far. You have not yet finished Lanterns, right?
Jessica
Not yet.
Matthew
Okay. They give a very good example… have you gotten to the explanation of why Guy Gardner is the Lantern?
Jessica
I’ve gotten to the episodes that we talked about on our Lanterns episode.
Matthew
That’s fair. It does more to fill in that story, and I just really like the way the whole universe is coming together and fitting together. And on our Superman episode, we talked about how much we enjoyed, and we’ll get into this as we start talking about Superman himself, just the idea of Superman in conversation with these other heroes, and how much that works. So I don’t like political censorship, but also I just hope that they let Gunn continue to cook, because he was coming up with something really good.
Jessica
Well, and he has said that he found it to be a lot to be actually making movies and also running the studio, which is fair. I genuinely agree that that is probably too many hats for any one person to wear. And if they were to let him continue to make the movies with the vision that he has for them, and he’s just not hiring and firing people… obviously, hiring and firing people is also an extremely political decision. A producer or a studio head can leverage a lot in one direction or the other. But if they were just going to let him continue to make movies, I would be perfectly happy with that. I mean, if you look at the trajectory that we’ve been on, Supergirl did not do so well at the box office, Superman did phenomenally well, the TV shows have been critically acclaimed. This was a strong trajectory, and it would be logical to continue that, especially since DC in particular has gotten its fair share of mockery, including from me, for their inability to create a cohesive universe or have a vision or compete in any way with Marvel. And that’s a bit of a double-edged sword, because Marvel has gotten a bit top-heavy. More than a bit top-heavy. But the other thing about James Gunn…
Matthew
Let me just say one thing about that. That to me is not even coincidental, it’s very related. This is kind of that time where the Yankees have been dominant for a while, but all their best players are retiring. Marvel is on a downswing, and I hope it comes back.
Jessica
They’re not allowed to retire. Chris Evans wanted to leave so badly.
Matthew
I know.
Jessica
They pull you back like that.
Matthew
And it’s entirely possible. Maybe Doomsday is going to be great, and they’re going to be back with a vengeance. But I think there’s definitely a window right now, and a lot of Marvel fatigue that DC was really starting to step into. So I kind of hope they continue.
Jessica
Well, and this is sort of related, because this is all very relevant to how the comic book universe works, where people don’t want to get into comics because it’s 60 to 80 years of history that they don’t want to deal with. And now the movies have become daunting, because you should be able to just rock up to the movie theater and see a superhero movie, but now you need to watch, what, 27 movies to even have the bare bones of… and that’s not even everything. Whereas DC is more in that very DC Comics cycle of constantly rebooting, and for a second getting something good, and then exploding it with another reboot, because surely if we do it again, we’ll hit it this time. But the thing about Gunn is, he’s a nerd. He reads this stuff, he gets it. And I think that he is so suited to making these films because he has a really good balance between having a genuine knowledge and love and appreciation for all the esoteric, Byzantine weirdness of a comic book universe, while also understanding that most people don’t…
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
…and being able to translate that to a larger audience. Again, there’s stuff like The People v. Jimmy Olsen, which is so comic booky, but he can translate that for people who aren’t neck-deep in comics. And this Latcham guy, I’m looking at a Variety article. You asked when in the MCU: he was an associate producer on Iron Man, so he’s been there for a few years.
Matthew
Okay, so he’s been there for a while.
Jessica
Yeah. But there are quotes here saying he brings a deep reverence for DC and its passionate fan base, recognizing that they are the very foundation of this storied, multi-generational brand. There’s a lot about his nerd bona fides, which could be a good thing, could be a very bad thing.
Matthew
Yeah. No, that’s very fair. That’s very fair. So we will see where that goes. But we’re here today mostly to talk about Superman, and Paul Hoppe, my normal co-host, can’t join us, but he sent us a quote. I want to read this to you and let you respond to it, and then let that kick off our conversation. Paul says, “Superman was the first superhero I loved. The idea that it’s possible for someone to have so much power and to use it responsibly for good is an important idea. I’ve never bought the idea that power corrupts, and Superman provides hope that a person can be true to their values regardless of how much power they hold. I think it’s something worth aspiring to. If we say power corrupts, then every person who uses their power to harm others is let off the hook.”
Jessica
I mean, nailed it.
Matthew
Yeah, that is a really great point at the end there. And let’s talk about that, because it feels to me like with Superman, there have always been two different kinds of stories. One is, like everybody else, the story is about whether he’ll have enough power in order to overcome.
And they do that in two ways. One is someone limits his power, generally with kryptonite in some weird form, whatever it is. And the other is that he has to challenge someone who is as godlike powerful as he is. That might be other Kryptonians like General Zod, it might be Darkseid, it might be literal gods, it might be whoever. Where do you see this idea of Superman being so powerful, and whether the story should be about challenging his power or challenging how he uses his power?
Jessica
I mean, in terms of “should,” I don’t want to be too prescriptive here. There are really excellent stories about Superman going up against somebody who’s really physically strong. Those exist. That’s sort of a gimme. To me, Superman is most interesting not when you take away his power or when you put him up against somebody who can go toe-to-toe with him, but when he is confronting something that punching can’t solve. And I think that’s why the other half of his existence is so important, because Clark Kent is a reporter, right? And he’s an investigative journalist, specifically. I mean, he’s been everything, but he’s an investigative journalist, and so much of that is finding the other ways that people use power and abuse power, use power to hurt others. And he can’t just go in and punch a CEO or a corrupt elected official or Lex Luthor or whoever, unless Lex Luthor is wearing his robot gear…
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
Right. I mean, he could, but he’s not going to do that, and it’s not actually going to solve the problem. Obviously, with Superman, you need to come up with a story that juggles both, so that he’s doing something visually interesting, but it’s also not narratively boring, because, what, they’re going to punch each other for 120 minutes and then we can go home?
Matthew
Right. I have loved so much of the MCU, and I think the early parts of it were fantastic, but one of the biggest complaints I often had about it was how much they love the symmetrical villain. Captain America had Red Skull, who had a similar kind of serum used to create him. The Hulk had the other Hulk. Iron Man had Iron Monger. It was always someone who has a similar power set. And I love that the strongest, the most powerful, the most superpowered person in the world, his main nemesis is a businessman. And that’s why I hate Lex Luthor in the mecha suit, because I don’t want him to punch. I want it to be the idea that Superman knows his power set is kind of useless against Lex Luthor. Because sure, he can kill him. A, that means he’s now kind of a murderer, but also B, it means someone else would just come along and do the same thing. It’s: can Clark Kent expose him? Can Superman stop his things from happening, but not just punch him to death?
Jessica
Exactly. And then you do the thing where Lex teams up with, I don’t know, not Darkseid, Darkseid’s not going to lower himself, Mongul, or Parasite, one of Superman’s punchy villains, and then you get to have Superman fighting somebody across the streets of Metropolis, in the skies, catching buildings that are toppling over, saving Lois and Jimmy. But ultimately there is a genuine challenge for him that makes us feel like he’s a character that we can relate to and want to root for. And the thing is, this is not an original idea to me, I’ve seen it expressed by multiple people, but Superman is a power fantasy, right? And I think the very boring expression of that is, “Oh, what if you had the power to do whatever you wanted? You’re super strong, you could just…” Because that’s not what he does anyway.
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
The more compelling one to me is, what if you had the power to help everyone?
Matthew
Right. Right. And how would you do that, and what would it look like? And I think it’s interesting, two of the movies, and I don’t think either one of these is a great Superman movie, I think one of them’s much better than the other, but two of the movies with some of the most powerful villains he goes up against: one is Superman II, the Donner movies, the first time that we see Zod appear, and the other is Batman v Superman. In both, there’s this super powerful person who’s fighting Superman, whether it’s Zod and his buddies, or it’s Batman, or it’s eventually Doomsday. But in both, it’s Lex Luthor behind the scenes, pulling the strings.
And I think you’re right that that presents a really interesting thing, where yes, there’s this super powerful thing he has to fight, but really it’s Lex doing it. I mean, even in the most recent one, he has to fight Bizarro, he has to fight all these other things…
Jessica
Yeah.
Matthew
…but it’s Lex in just a suit, pushing buttons on a computer, who’s really making it all happen.
Jessica
Which is also, if you think about it, Lex trying to express the power fantasy of “what if I was really strong and I could do whatever I wanted,” and that’s how he fails every time, because he’s much better at the sneaky part, but his big guy is just going to get punched out. This is Superman. Get a little genre savvy, Lex.
Matthew
That would help. That would certainly help. And that’s why in some instances he becomes president, or becomes a political leader, or things like that.
Jessica
Yeah, which, that story feels so sweetly innocent now.
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
He divested from LexCorp when he became president. Imagine such a thing.
Matthew
Lex Luthor was less corrupt than our billionaire president.
Jessica
He sure was. And he got impeached because he put on his green and purple armor and tried to kill Superman.
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
And he was still more ethical and less corrupt.
Matthew
I remember reading something saying that, with Ebenezer Scrooge, if you translate the economics of Victorian England to today… oh god, it’s not Marley, what’s the main… Cratchit was getting the equivalent of like two or three times the American minimum wage, in terms of how much Scrooge was or wasn’t screwing over his workers. Okay, so back to that. I think one of the things that I like about that idea with investigative journalism is, one part of it is getting information out there, but as a journalist, you’re not a prosecuting attorney, you’re not the police. The point is that you’re supposed to give someone the information so that they can take action. And that to me is a part of the hope thing: it feels like a lot of what Clark Kent does, but also Superman, is inspire others to act. Talk about that, and how you see that as a part of all this.
Jessica
Well, it’s interesting that you segued from the President Lex stuff to that, because that is why, canonically, in the comics, Clark did not interfere in the election. I mean, also, that would have been wrong, but he trusted the American people to make the right choice at that time. Oops. Yeah, we all have a miss here or there.
Matthew
Yeah. But yeah, no, I think that’s a great point. He’s not Matt Murdock, right? He’s…
Jessica
He’s just giving people the information, because he believes that in the aggregate, people are generally good and will do the right thing if they are given the resources to make good choices. And I think that’s absolutely an effect of how he was raised by Jonathan, and those are the kinds of values that he was instilled with. And I think it’s a really interesting corollary to Lois, especially early on. They both change because they know each other, but Lois is typically much more cynical than Clark when they first meet, which makes it interesting that Clark is more about getting the information out there because he thinks people will do the right thing with it, and Lois is more about getting the information out there because she thinks people are doing the wrong thing in secret.
Matthew
Uh-huh. Yeah.
Jessica
They kind of meet in the middle.
Matthew
Uh-huh. And I think that’s such a powerful dynamic, and I think this is part of why I’ve started to really like Superman more in some of the most recent tellings. Because for me, the idea of “I have all this power and I’m going to just use it to help. I see a problem, I’m going to fix the problem,” there’s something kind of naive about that. I’m sort of thinking, if you’re fixing the problems you’re seeing, are you privileging the problems you’re seeing versus the ones you’re not seeing? And what does that say about your own biases, or things like that? And also, how often are you seeing a problem, but you’re only seeing the tip of the iceberg? Landlords, I think, are also pretty terrible, but I often think, okay, how often is it that the landlord is doing something terrible because their taxes are going up? Some of them are just super greedy landlords, and some of them are being squeezed. Or the conversations we can have about beating up street kids who are working for a villain. Would it actually do better to create a jobs program, so that they didn’t feel like they had to go work for this crazy villain, because they had better economic opportunities? Things like that.
And I feel like one of the things that I loved most about the new movie, because the line of thinking I’m talking about can lead to an incredible amount of cynicism, was especially that conversation that Clark and Lois have about his interfering in this international conflict. That’s the moment where his naivete and her cynicism hit up against each other, and to me, neither one is wrong. The idea is that he needs her to challenge him and she needs him to challenge her. Do you think that’s kind of a fair statement?
Jessica
Yeah, I think that’s a sign of a really well-written Clark and Lois. I certainly wouldn’t say that that applies to every iteration of them. Or even your point earlier, about “if I see a problem, I’m going to solve it,” requires you to be able to see the problems. That’s why Clark is a journalist. That’s explicitly why he’s a journalist, because that way he’s paying attention to what the problems are. He’s literally getting as much information as he can about them. But all of this, I think it’s not a given, right?
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
It is there to be utilized, it’s there in the DNA of Superman, but it requires a good writer, which is sort of saying nothing, because any superhero story requires a good writer to be good. But that’s sort of the crux of it, right? We’re telling these stories that are about such primal things, like good and evil and justice and compassion, really big concepts, and it’s so easy to fall into stereotypes or cliches instead of really thinking through what it is your characters are representing, and what it is they’re saying, and where the things they’re saying don’t match up with what you’re actually having them do.
Matthew
Right.
Jessica
And I think that scene in the movie is just such a phenomenal demonstration of who both of these characters are, the central concepts of Superman as a concept, concepts as a concept, you get what I mean, and why the relationship works, and exactly what you said: they balance each other, they need each other, and they’re better with each other.
Matthew
Yeah. And I get why it can happen a lot with Lois, and I think it’s really good. I love a romance, and I know you do too, so I think that pairing makes a lot of sense. But some of my favorite versions are pairing him with Batman, and Zack Snyder, I’m decidedly not looking at you, but especially in the Justice League comic and cartoon, I feel like you get a lot of great examples where that’s Batman as well. Batman is “I don’t trust anyone,” and Superman is “I trust everyone.” And Batman will be like, “You idiot, of course they voted for Lex.” And Superman will be like, “Batman, you’ve got to have more hope in people. Look, they did rise up when you thought they wouldn’t.” And both of them are clashing like that. Does that make sense?
Jessica
Yeah, absolutely. And they’re also really good foils for each other, again, when written well. And the thing about a foil is, they can’t be total opposites.
There has to be that bit of overlap. And Bruce does have that optimism, or he wouldn’t be doing what he does. Why bother being Batman? And Clark has the cynicism to know that he is needed to do what he does.
Matthew
Right.
Jessica
And they can kind of cross streams that way and get each other, and ultimately are striving toward the same goal, with not dissimilar methodology.
Matthew
It depends, again, on the version. So one thing I’ve noticed, and I wonder if this is just because, again, I don’t know the comics as well, and you’re going to tell me that there’s a lot of this there that I just haven’t seen. One thing that marks a lot of my favorite heroes, and the three that most come to mind are Spider-Man, Batman, and the Flash, is that they often have villains who have a sympathetic backstory. And those characters, especially Peter, but also the other two, will sometimes be like, “Hey, look, you’re hurting people because you’re hurt. Can I help you?”
Like the Flash trying to talk Captain Cold out of doing the things he’s doing, because, “Hey, look, maybe we can get you a better way to handle this.” Or Batman being like, “Mr. Freeze, can I help you with your wife, instead of you having to do this?” Superman seems like the sort of person who’d be very on board with that kind of thing. I don’t remember seeing him do that in many of his movies. Is that a story you see from him a lot in his comics, or is it because, to give him a villain, it has to be either someone who is so corrupt, like Luthor, or so mind-bendingly powerful, like Darkseid, that there just isn’t room for that story?
Jessica
I mean, he definitely tries with Lex. It depends on the continuity. But there are multiple versions of continuity, including the one we’re in currently, where he and Lex were childhood friends. They go way back. I mean, Smallville, the TV show, adapted them as homoerotically as it possibly could. Just an innocent childhood friendship between a 16-year-old and a 25-year-old. A 25-year-old who keeps buying him expensive cars.
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
Yeah, buddies. But they do have this history. And Lex was friends with, again, it depends on the continuity, both Clark and Superboy. So when Superman turns to him and is like, “We were friends, why can’t we be like we were? It’s not like I don’t know you. I knew Clark Kent,” there is a history there, and he does try to reach Lex that way when that is a thing that’s in their backstory. With General Zod, or any, quote unquote, evil Kryptonian, especially in versions of the universe where there’s no Supergirl, that’s all he has of his home world. He desperately wants to have a positive relationship with other Kryptonians, any Kryptonian. He wants that so badly, but he’s not going to let them take over the planet so that they’ll be his friend. There are other villains, like Atomic Skull, who I think has been in some of the cartoons. He’s never going to make it into a movie, but he’s basically reformed now. He’s friendly with Superman. He tries to help Parasite a lot. Silver Banshee is currently dating Jimmy Olsen, totally reformed at the moment.
Matthew
Okay. Sure. Yeah.
Jessica
Supergirl does this a lot too. I would say this is a little bit more of a thing with Supergirl than it is with Superman, which, we can unpack what that means about stereotyping women as being more compassionate and caretaking and forgiving, but it’s definitely a thing. It’s just, I guess, not cinematically interesting enough or whatever.
Matthew
You know, Batman does have a tendency to be a lot more likely to try to help someone overcome their evil urges if they look like Poison Ivy or Harley Quinn, or someone like that.
Jessica
Yeah. Superman doesn’t have a lot of female villains. It’s like Silver Banshee, and that’s it.
Matthew
And there’s very little overlap, right? I can’t ever think of seeing a comic of Superman going up against the Joker, even, or Harley Quinn, or Catwoman, or anything like that.
Jessica
I mean, what are they going to do? It has happened, but what are they going to do? Seriously, Harley Quinn’s going to hit him with the big hammer? There are a few instances of the Joker going to Metropolis and starting shit, and Clark pretty much just picks him up by the scruff, takes him back to Arkham, and tells Bruce to watch him, or he will not like what happens. He is not having it.
There is one story where the Joker poisons Lois. This is while Clark and Lois are engaged, so they’re in a very serious relationship, but he’s also kind of having an emotional affair with his college girlfriend, Lori Lemaris, who is a mermaid.
Matthew
As you do.
Jessica
As you do. And so they’re already kind of on the rocks, and the Joker poisons Lois and tells Batman and Superman that the only way to get the antidote is for Superman to kill him, the Joker. And Superman’s like, “I mean, all right.” And Batman’s like, “No, you can’t become a killer, blah, blah, blah,” and talks him down from it. And Superman’s like, “Okay, fine, I won’t kill him.” And the Joker’s like, “I was just kidding anyway. She’s fine. It wore off. I was just messing with you. I’m the Joker. Woo-hoo.” And Clark goes back to Lois and is like, “Crazy thing happened today. I know you weren’t feeling well. Turns out the Joker poisoned you, but don’t worry, I would not have killed him to save your life.” And Lois is like, “Hey, I’m going to call off the engagement.”
Matthew
Yeah, that’s fair. That’s fair. That’s not the romantic thing.
Jessica
So yeah. They did that because they couldn’t get married yet, because this is when Lois & Clark was airing, and they weren’t ready to get married on the show, and they needed the comic to come out at the same time that that episode aired. So Lois went and climbed the Himalayas for a while, and then the TV show was like, “Wedding episode,” and she was like, “Got to get back to Metropolis.” It was all very dumb. I like it. But yes, Superman has fought the Joker, and it’s not much of a fight.
Matthew
Well, now I’m kind of imagining Batman and the Joker… because the Joker is often trying to tell Batman, “You’re not one of them, all those normal people.” And I can imagine Batman in a moment of frustration with the big blue Boy Scout, and the Joker kind of having a heart-to-heart with him about that. So that’d be fun.
And that actually lets me get to the last question I want to ask, before getting back to Paul’s thing as kind of a wrap-up. I don’t know how well you know D&D, but to me, Lex Luthor and the Joker are really good embodiments of lawful evil versus chaotic evil. And I think it’s fitting that Superman fights lawful evil, because he is himself pretty much lawful good.
He wants to work for truth, justice, and the American way, and I would never call him a vigilante. There’s always a sense that he does this with the approval of the powers that be. Batman fights chaotic evil because he is chaotic good, or chaotic neutral, if you want to call him that.
Jessica
He’s neutral good, I would say.
Matthew
Okay, fair, fair. But he exists in a world where law doesn’t really exist, where fundamentally it’s a very corrupt system and all this kind of stuff. Turns out dividing the entire world into nine different ideas of morality is a little bit limiting.
Jessica
Doesn’t totally work.
Matthew
Exactly. But yes, Superman does have this idea of “I’m part of the authorities,” in a way that Batman fundamentally is not, and there are some stories where he’s not, obviously. But part of where I’m going with this is that one of the things that has had to evolve with the Batman story is that Batman was started in a world when rich people were people we admired, people who built universities and built libraries and all sorts of great things like that. And yes, there was some frustration with them, but for most of the Batman story, the fact that he was a billionaire didn’t make him suspect.
I hit my mic. The fact that he’s a billionaire didn’t make him suspect. In the last 15 years, that has fundamentally changed. And I think a lot of the criticism often is, “Hey, he’s a billionaire. If he wants to fix poverty, he doesn’t do it as Batman, he does it as Bruce Wayne.” And in some of the more recent stories, there’s been a lot more about, can you be a person fighting evil if you’re a billionaire? And how can Bruce Wayne use his money, and not have his money, in order to make things better?
I’m wondering to what extent that’s happened with Superman. Because in the same way, he’s the big blue Boy Scout. He’s the person who works with the cops and who works with the American government, because those are fundamentally good things. The idea that that isn’t true… I mean, there have been people criticizing billionaires since the ’30s, and there have been people criticizing the American government and the police just as long. But I think the idea of, “Oh, I work with the cops, I work with the government, so I’m one of the good guys,” that’s changed a lot.
How do you feel like Superman has adapted, or should adapt, to a very different understanding of what all that means?
Jessica
Yeah, I mean, I think again, I want to bring up their secret identities.
Matthew
Mm-hmm.
Jessica
Because I question the idea that Batman is not part of established authority, but Bruce Wayne definitely is.
Matthew
That’s very true.
Jessica
And I understand what you’re saying, that Batman is a vigilante, but the way that he moves through the world, regardless of whether he’s wearing a mask or not, is as an immensely privileged white man. That’s just how he interacts with other people. That’s how he interacts with Clark, who is also very… not quite as privileged, but similar levels of privilege. Whereas with Superman, I mean, similar to Batman, he was a vigilante when he started out. They both were. And I would be very curious to unpack public opinion toward millionaires, Bruce wasn’t a billionaire then, toward the tail end of the Great Depression. I mean, he wasn’t even a millionaire then. He was just a playboy about town. I think that’d be really interesting to unpack. But in terms of reporters, reporters were viewed heroically. That career was given to Clark and Lois because it was a cool, badass hero career.
Matthew
Yeah, that’s very true.
Jessica
And I think we have very much lost the idea of the crusading, heroic journalist, which I wish we hadn’t. I want it to come back. In the way that Batman sort of operates outside of the establishment while Bruce Wayne sits at the top of it, Superman could be argued to operate at the top of the establishment, because even though he’s not an official part of it, he’s more powerful than any member of it.
Matthew
Right.
Jessica
Even if he’s not officially deputized, what are they going to do, tell him no? But Clark Kent’s whole job is to interrogate it, and I think that’s really interesting, again, when we’re talking about them as foils. But in terms of Superman being this manifestation of the establishment or the patriarchy, that also depends on what era you’re looking at. In the ’30s and early ’40s, he was very much this populist, rabble-rouser kind of figure who was unearthing corruption in both of his identities. And then with the adoption of the Comics Code and the shift into the McCarthy era, he became this much more staid, patriarchal figure who supported the American government and all forms of authority, and was constantly scolding and lecturing Lois Lane and Jimmy Olsen and Supergirl for being too young and/or too girl. I don’t know that he’s ever totally gotten away from that.
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
Because he’s viewed as so wholesome, and we have been so trained to view our symbols of patriotism, our country and our government and our elected officials and the police, as wholesome. Or at least, well, I say “we.” That is the dominant cultural narrative. Obviously, there are many groups within the US, leaving aside the rest of the world, who do not view those groups that way. Black people and Indigenous people have been fed that propaganda, but with some very harsh realities at the same time that white people have been sort of inured to. It’s not something I think that anybody making Superman stories pursues anymore, but it lingers. And there are creators who come in and do try to unpack it and untangle those threads, but yeah, the cultural way that these very old characters are viewed carries a lot of inertia.
Matthew
Yeah, no, I think that’s very true. And in some ways I was thinking that the most embattled person in terms of the press is more the Perry White character, in terms of the decisions they have to make. And I could easily see, as you said, journalism is seen very differently than it was 30 years ago, 50 years ago. And I think in some ways the newspapers have been the last to be hit by that. There’s no such thing as Walter Cronkite anymore, or the way the CBS reporters who went to Vietnam were seen. Today, whether it’s Fox or CNN or MSNBC, any of these are seen as very jaded and very slanted one way or the other. And I agree much more with the MSNBC types, but I still don’t think it’s a well-rounded perspective of the news.
I think the New York Times is still maybe the closest thing to the Daily Bugle, but it’s still very biased on some issues, in some really problematic ways. And I could even see, probably not in a TV thing, but… actually, you never saw Superman & Lois, right? The show that was kind of a continuation of Smallville?
Jessica
Just bits and pieces.
Matthew
Yeah. A part of that is that Lois quits her big newspaper job and winds up fighting to start a local newspaper, and then also having a blog to some extent, because the Daily Bugle is getting economic pressure to not write the challenging stories and stuff like that. And I could totally see Clark Kent one day having a blog, or some other thing where he’s like…
Jessica
Oh, he’s done it.
Matthew
Okay, that’s awesome.
Jessica
At the beginning of the New 52, he screams at everybody in the newsroom that they’ve lost sight of their journalistic integrity, and he’s leaving, he’s quitting, he’s starting a blog.
Matthew
Oh, my God.
Jessica
And Cat Grant, who is very different, this is not the Calista Flockhart version, basically Jerry Maguires him, like, “I’ll go with you,” and they go and they start a blog, and it’s pretty embarrassing, because this is already after the peak of blogs, so it was like…
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
Oh, this was not a good thing. But yeah, the struggle for independent and ethical journalism has been part of the push and pull of Superman, not since the beginning, but for at least 50 years. In the ’70s, the Daily Planet was bought by a broadcasting corporation, and they all got a new boss who was much more… well, they got a new boss who was a minion of Darkseid, but then it turned out he was a clone. The clone died, and the real guy came back, and the real guy was kind of a jerk, but not a minion of Darkseid, just much more interested in ratings than journalistic integrity. There have been times when Lex has bought the Daily Planet, or Perry has been ousted. I mean, currently Perry is the mayor of Metropolis and Lois is the editor. So there’s all sorts of that. And then of course you have to interrogate the journalistic integrity of a man who goes and blows out a fire with his super-lungs and then writes it down like, “Superman was especially handsome today.”
Matthew
And that’s all, again, something I loved about the movie, when Lois was like, “You’ve never really had a hostile interview, because you interview yourself. That’s not good journalism.”
Jessica
I mean, to give him credit, he definitely moves back and forth to either side of the table to give it some verisimilitude, but she’s right.
Matthew
Yeah, I’m sure. Well, this has been fantastic. I kind of want to wrap up. We both fully agreed with what Paul said, but I wanted you to go a little bit deeper on that idea, that one of the cynical ideas can be that power corrupts, and so anybody with power is going to get corrupted. I feel like we do get stories of Superman’s power being corrupted, but generally it’s because he’s near red kryptonite. It’s chemically induced. What do you think is the importance to the Superman story of him being someone who does have this power, but is basically incorruptible?
Jessica
I mean, again, it’s that power fantasy, right? What if you had enough power to help everyone? And also, what if somebody was powerful enough to help you?
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
But also, the thing that I’ve harped on many a time about Superman, and I’m sure I’ve done it on your show, is that Clark Kent is not Peter Parker. Peter Parker is a nerd. He gets bullied. The cool kids don’t want to hang out with him. And then he gets bitten by a spider and his life changes. But he starts out as a nerd. Clark Kent has at times been depicted as a nerd, but that’s not… he’s mild-mannered Clark Kent, right? He’s a nonentity. He’s forgettable. People don’t notice him. To me, that has always been very much about how the ordinary person does have great power within themselves. We all have an immense capacity for change. And not to be too hooked on hopium right now, but I think last week really showed that ordinary people can enact, or start to enact, significant change. Because so much of that work, even aside from every individual who voted and the candidates who ran, so much of that work, especially in the South, was done by diligent effort over years, if not decades, by organizers. And so the idea of Superman being relatable, because we can all take our glasses off, metaphorically, and put on our cape and make change…
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
If we then say that that power we have is ultimately a source of corruption…
Matthew
Mm-hmm.
Jessica
…it undercuts it. It undercuts all the power in that. You have the capacity to do good things, and you have the choice to use that capacity to do good things rather than to do selfish or cruel things. They’re all part of the same thing.
Matthew
No, I love that. And this really makes this conversation a great follow-up to the one that, we’re recording this on Monday, will come out tomorrow, but will be the one the week before this one is released. Because we recorded that one on Spider-Man and the idea of great responsibility, and we recorded it on Election Day. And we talked a lot about how maybe the point is not to think about the huge people with huge responsibility, but, as you said, how we all have a responsibility, how we all have that kind of power.
And so we got into a fun discussion, and I’m going to end with the conversation that we spent a long time on in regards to Spider-Man, but ask you here. What would Superman think of Curtis Sliwa? For those who didn’t hear last week, Curtis Sliwa was the head of a group called the Guardian Angels, who were quite literal vigilantes, and most of what they did was on the side of legality. They were a visible presence, where people knew that if you start shit while they’re around, bad stuff’s going to happen. They did physically intervene in some instances where bad stuff was happening. They did physically intervene in some cases where they thought people were going to start bad stuff, and it may well have been that the color of someone’s skin was more the evidence that they thought bad stuff was going to happen than actual bad stuff happening. But these were people who were like, “Look, we have responsibility, we have power, let’s use it to try and…” And not to defend them, but it happened at a time when New York City looked an awful lot more like Gotham than Metropolis, in terms of the police being really defanged. I mean, it led to Giuliani, and I’m not saying that’s better by any means, but there was a lot of bad stuff happening that the police weren’t doing much about. What’s your take on what Superman would have thought of vigilantes stepping into that situation?
Jessica
Well, just to add some crucial context to Curtis Sliwa: he also runs as the Republican candidate for mayor of New York City every mayoral election, and at this point he has just become this beloved cartoon character that nobody takes seriously.
Matthew
Yeah, he’s like the Naked Cowboy.
Jessica
There’s a phrase that people use, that he’s the kind of thing that makes New York New York. And yeah, he’s like Mamdani’s Wario, except he’s been here way longer than Mamdani.
Matthew
And when he lost the Republican nomination, he was like, “Well, of course Mamdani’s better than Cuomo. Cuomo’s horrible.”
Jessica
Oh, yeah, yeah.
Matthew
If you’re looking for a Republican who does seem to retain integrity…
Jessica
And also wears the same hat every single day, because he is an actual cartoon character. Come to New York. We have bagels and Curtis Sliwa. But I don’t have to guess, because it happens all the time, where it’s like, here’s a new vigilante in Metropolis, and he’s dealing with street crime that Superman doesn’t notice, and whoops, it’s all gone wrong. Gangbuster is one of the best known ones, and Superman has to swing in and be like, “Hey, don’t do that.” But generally he winds up making a friend of them. I think it is hard, when you are Teflon, to watch other people throw themselves into these situations. And certainly when somebody is making bad calls, as you described happening, yeah, I think Superman would put a stop to that. But in terms of how he’d feel about Curtis Sliwa today, I think he and Lois would fight over who got to interview him every mayoral cycle.
Matthew
That’s probably true.
Jessica
That’s the most fun interview every three years.
Matthew
Yeah, no, that’s very true. All right, well, Jessica, this has been great. Any last things you wanted to say that we haven’t gotten to get into?
Jessica
Thank you for letting me come on the show now 38 times to change your mind about Superman. I like to think I’ve moved the needle just a little.
Matthew
You definitely have. I don’t think I would have understood and gotten the James Gunn movie without you. And I would say that I really love the James Gunn version of Superman. That is a hero I can really get behind, and I think you’ve helped me much better understand that. I’m still a Batman guy, but I’m also now like, yeah, Batman is great, but Batman needs Superman, you know?
Jessica
They’re buddies.
Matthew
Yeah, they really should be. They really should be. Except Wonder Woman should wind up with Batman, not Superman. So just putting that out there.
Jessica
I mean, if we have to pick, then yeah, Batman.
Matthew
Yeah.
Jessica
I mean, really, Wonder Woman should wind up with Poison Ivy and Harley, and the three of them can sort of argue about morality, but that’s a whole different story.
Matthew
Anyway. And you say this now that Archive of Our Own is down for weeks.
Jessica
Oh my god.
Matthew
Yeah, I have seen a couple people be like, “Look, I don’t want to punish people, but if this is the result of all of that pent-up frustration coming out another way, can we shut down Archive of Our Own for a week every two years?”
Jessica
Right? Right. No.
Matthew
All right. Well, thank you so much, Jessica. If people want to find your other writings, not necessarily on Archive of Our Own, but in other places, where can they find your writings?
Jessica
Well, I do a lot of writing on comics at BookRiot.com, and my debut novel, which is not about comics, is coming out next September. It’s called Magestruck. It will be out with Harlequin. It is a queer fantasy rom-com, and you can find more information about it on my website, JessicaPlummerWrites.com. It is available for preorder.
Matthew
And I’m excited about it, and everybody should read it. I look forward to hearing about it. Well, thank you all so much. Please check out all the great things Jessica does, and all of us.