Holy Multimedia Event, Batman!
Join hosts Krissy Lenz and Nathan Blackwell with special guests Andy Nelson and Kyle Olson as they dive deep into Tim Burton’s groundbreaking Batman (1989)—recorded live at the 2025 Phoenix Fan Fusion! This wasn’t just a movie—it was a cultural phenomenon that changed everything we thought we knew about comic book adaptations.
Michael Keaton’s Controversial Casting & Performance
The hosts discuss the massive fan backlash when Michael Keaton was cast as the Dark Knight, fresh off his comedic role in Beetlejuice. Thousands of angry letters poured in, but Keaton proved everyone wrong with his brooding, murderous take on Batman that shocked audiences expecting the campy 1960s TV version.
Jack Nicholson’s Iconic Joker
From his pre-accident mob boss persona to his chemical-scarred transformation, Nicholson’s Joker became the gold standard for Batman villains. The podcast explores his elaborate makeup process, brilliant branding schemes, and surprisingly sympathetic balloon scene that made audiences feel bad for Gotham’s Clown Prince of Crime.
Tim Burton’s Dark Gothic Vision
Burton created a Gotham City so grimy and noir it felt like 1970s New York at its worst. The hosts praise the film’s revolutionary approach to superhero storytelling—taking the genre seriously for the first time since Superman while establishing the template for modern comic book movies.
Other Topics Covered:
• The film’s massive $411 million box office success and cultural impact
• Batman’s surprisingly murderous methods compared to modern interpretations
• The practical challenges of the original Batsuit (couldn’t turn his head!)
• Prince’s soundtrack and the unprecedented multimedia marketing blitz
• Behind-the-scenes studio mandates including the bell tower finale
• Robin Williams casting controversy and Hollywood politics
• Vicki Vale’s problematic romance subplot and 80s dating culture
• The film’s influence on superhero movie merchandising
• Comparing different Batman actors across generations
Final Verdict
All four hosts give Burton’s Batman a solid 8 out of 10, praising its entertainment value, groundbreaking tone, and lasting influence while acknowledging some dated elements. This episode proves why Batman (1989) remains the definitive Dark Knight for an entire generation of fans.
Subscribe to The Most Excellent 80s Movies Podcast for more deep dives into the decade’s greatest films!
