In this spirited discussion of Star Wars: Episode IX – The Rise of Skywalker, hosts Matthew, Alex, and Erin dive deep into the controversial conclusion of the Skywalker saga. From shocking revelations to questionable plot decisions, the hosts explore both the film’s greatest strengths and most puzzling weaknesses, offering unique perspectives on why this final chapter divides fans so deeply.
Did Emperor Palpatine’s return undermine Anakin’s sacrifice? The hosts tackle this contentious plot point, with Alex arguing that while the execution was flawed, having Palpatine as the ultimate puppet master makes thematic sense within the larger Star Wars story. They explore how subsequent Star Wars shows have actually helped retroactively justify this controversial choice.
Was Rey’s Palpatine heritage reveal worth undoing The Last Jedi‘s “nobody” twist? The discussion examines how this dramatic shift impacted Rey’s character arc and the larger themes of the sequel trilogy, particularly the message about heroism coming from anywhere.
Should Ben Solo have survived? The hosts debate the controversial ending, including the kiss between Rey and Ben, questioning whether his death was necessary and if it served the story effectively.
Other key topics covered:
- How the rushed 16-hour timeline affected the film’s pacing and credibility
- The underutilization of Rose Tico and the real-world circumstances that led to it
- The mystery of Finn’s unspoken message to Rey
- The wasted potential of the Knights of Ren
- The surprising effectiveness of Hux as a spy and his abrupt death
- The visual spectacle of Exegol and the film’s impressive set pieces
- The powerful moment featuring voices of past Jedi
- Lando’s return and the revelation about Jannah’s identity
Despite its flaws, the hosts acknowledge the film’s strengths as a fun adventure movie with stunning visuals and exciting moments. While it may not have stuck the landing as the conclusion to a nine-film saga, The Rise of Skywalker remains an entertaining, if divisive, entry in the Star Wars canon that continues to spark passionate discussion among fans.
