*This transcript is produced using transcription software and reviewed for quality. Despite our best efforts, some passages may be incomplete or contain errors due to audio quality or software limitations.*
Pete Wright:
I’m Pete Wright.
Andy Nelson:
And I’m Andy Nelson.
Pete Wright:
Welcome to The Next Reel when the movie ends.
Andy Nelson:
Our conversation begins.
Pete Wright:
The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is over. You can kiss my asssssssssssssssss. This is your pick.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, yeah.
Pete Wright:
But I was an enthusiastic supporter of doing this series.
Andy Nelson:
franchise has been huge. My brain always says that the Film Board covered a number of the films, but every time I look, I’m like, oh, they only covered one of them. So I always—
Pete Wright:
I don’t think I can even tell you which one it was.
Andy Nelson:
It is Mockingjay Part One.
Pete Wright:
We only did Mockingjay Part One and then we gave up.
Andy Nelson:
We only did, yeah. Well we did I and it’s funny because everyone loved Catching Fire so much.
Pete Wright:
Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
I think everybody was on board to oh, let’s do Mockingjay. And then I think that’s as far as it ended up happening. But I think this is a really fascinating franchise. And I, you know, I don’t necessarily love all of these all the films and the way everything unfolds, but I do think that it’s telling an interesting story and an interesting dystopian future. And so largely I enjoy what Suzanne Collins did with the books, which I just read all of the books, like in the past couple months just to try getting prepped for all of this. So I had a handle on you know the source material.
And I think that she created an interesting world. I really enjoy this future Panem, and this just really dark, dark world that I mean, I don’t know. I think there’s a lot of things that we can probably talk about as far as like why did this type of dystopian future where kids are killing each other suddenly become an okay thing. I don’t think it was just because of Battle Royale which had already been out there. Is it like after Columbine, the Columbine shootings? And kind of the and then September eleventh suddenly like we were okay with these darker stories where we’re young children were killing each other I don’t know, or is it just the American way of life? Maybe.
But I do find it to be a fascinating franchise and I, for one, think it’s interesting the way that Suzanne Collins wrote the books with the first trilogy and then went back to do this prequel that we’re talking about today, which is kind of—Coriolanus Snow’s origin story as the villain, right? And then the next one that we’ll be talking about next week. Sunrise on the Reaping, jumping forward forty years to the point where Haymitch is competing and we watch his story before we kind of then come to see what’s going on with Katniss Everdeen and the end of kind of this whole regime that the Capitol has been reigning over the remaining bits of what’s left of the United States essentially. So yeah, I find it fascinating
Pete Wright:
Is it is there another one coming? Is there a third before or a third one that’s after the Haymitch story?
Andy Nelson:
No, if there is going to be another novel that Suzanne Collins ends up writing I don’t think she’s announced it yet. I’ll probably do more research on that next week when we’re talking about sunrise, since that’s kind of the last of the films, but my I mean, we’re kind of just filling in some of the key characters that we’ve met over the course of it. And so I don’t think so. I haven’t heard. But then I also thought it would be interesting to kind of look at this in the timeline of Panem. So we’re watching from this is this takes place at the tenth Hunger Games and then moving forward all the way to the seventy-fifth. And so it should be interesting to kind of watch Panem take shape and the Hunger Games take shape and what it means and how this world survives.
Pete Wright:
I have read the original trilogy, the Katniss trilogy. I have not read these books. I only just got them from the library. They just came in. the first one just came in yesterday and I so I haven’t started it.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, I’m sure there’s wait lists because with a new movie coming out, everybody is trying to get them, yeah.
Pete Wright:
It’s been it’s been on my it’s been on my list for like twelve weeks.
Andy Nelson:
Yep, yep.
Pete Wright:
So I nailed it. So I can’t help but reflect on the challenges that come from having seen the rest of the movies before this one and having not read the book. And so I’m I want to lean on you a little bit for the character of Snow and the interpretation that the prequel book gives us of Snow.
That is, to my critique, the central problem with the movie, that I don’t believe Snow’s authoritarian turn is at all earned in this movie But what I hear is it very much is earned in the book. I found myself rooting for Snow way too long into this movie as a as a character, and I don’t feel like he I can’t believe I’m making this comparison. I don’t believe he successfully made the Anakin to Vader turn
Andy Nelson:
Wow.
Pete Wright:
Which is what we kind of needed for Snow, right? Like this is the start of his villain arc, and that’s not this movie.
Andy Nelson:
I can’t agree with you because I think it is there and I saw this movie two times before I ever read the book. So I felt like I got it out of the movie without needing to go back to the source material to kind of pull anything extra out of it. You know what I mean? So I guess that’s, you know, I well and it you know, just saying straight up, I mean this is a film that leaves audiences and critics very conflicted. You know, I found this quote from somebody at Vulture, Zoe Guy said that, quote, some critics view the 158-minute spectacle as an overwrought snooze fest, while others argue that the Ballad is the most satisfying entry in the entire franchise. And so I think that speaks to kind of the way that people are interpreting what’s going on with Coriolanus Snow, or Coryo, as they like to call him, and this journey that he takes, because I do think that there are all of these elements there that we’re kind of seeing over the course of the story, kind of how this person who believes he’s a good person, right?
He thinks that he’s good. He believes that he is a person who is on the side of the right. He you know, definitely I mean his father was prominent in the in the Capitol and was killed by somebody in the twelfth district. And so kind of start seeing that he I mean he does believe he writes this report that talks about how humans do need to be ruled or they’re gonna turn on each other. I think what we watch over the course of the story is how He rationalizes things constantly over the course of the whole story, whether it’s little bits of violence that he does or the way that he cheats over the course of it to try getting ahead because of the way that the Plinth Prize has been renegotiated as far as how it’s going to get given, all the way to the point where he is seeing that it’s okay to kind of turn on a friend because or you know, or behind his back, really, because he sees that what his friend is doing is potentially damaging.
And I don’t think that he means for his friend to necessarily get hung. But that is the result of his action. And so he keeps taking all of these little actions over the course of the film that really kind of sets him up for somebody who is very easily easy at rationalizing all of the things that he’s doing, including all the violence. Like he’s not he’s pretty put off by the violence from the beginning. Like the whole Hunger Games thing, he doesn’t he’s not really on the side of how violent it is, but over the course of the story, I mean, he gets much more violent to the point where he sees it as kind of this necessity and is totally fine committing acts of violence.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, I can see that. That rationalization part is is an important one, right? Because I mean he rationalizes from jump just the assignment. Right. And he’s rationalizing every one of his decisions to keep his tribute alive. He rationalizes himself in just pretzels.
Andy Nelson:
Right, yeah.
Pete Wright:
Right, which yeah, I get that. I feel I and I and I think I can come around. I can come around to that. And I like him a lot.
And that’s probably I mean, you know
Andy Nelson:
Him the actor, Tom Blyth.
Pete Wright:
Him the actor, Tom Blyth. I like Tom Blyth a lot, right? Like I found he’s very charismatic. Maybe that’s part of the problem. He bamboozled me with his on-screen charisma, into thinking he was too kind.
Andy Nelson:
Well, hey He becomes president. Obviously, people fall for people with a lot of charisma. And I think we’re seeing that, right? I mean, that’s it a lot of this speaks to the place that we’re in today.
Pete Wright:
Well, and you also have to have to separate the fact that I mean he’s what? He’s in his twenties right now, his early twenties probably. And there are a lot of years between now and when we meet him again. and a lot more rationalization to come to get him to Donald Sutherland. So I get all of that. But I just I think my watch and I’ve watched it twice But I think I think you and I are the split that that review you noted represents because the first time I watched this movie, it took me weeks to get through. Every 25 minutes I found myself so bored, I couldn’t continue. I had to do something else.
I couldn’t get through it. It is the curse of not having seen it in the theater that I could just pause it and go to the bathroom and never come back. I just couldn’t get through this movie. And so I watched it again last night with my kiddo and it was the same feeling of slog. Like this movie was mucking through a swamp to get to the end. It was it was just way, way too egregiously too long. for each of these three major chapters to be welcomed. And, you know, the challenges that that we saw, at least the comically stacked tropes of racism and ageism and ableism and it we just laughed at the movie more than with the movie.
And I so I found myself just being genuinely frustrated by this experience. Knowing also how much I’ve come to really like the later movies. So I wanted, I went in wanting this movie to be awesome. And I’ll say also, the trailer for the next movie looks Great. I can’t wait for that. So I want this to be my experience with the first Star Wars prequel. Let’s just get it out of the way, pretend it didn’t happen, and move on to Haymitch’s story.
Andy Nelson:
Oh wow. Well I hope I like I hope I like I mean I really did enjoy Sunrise on the Reaping, the book. And so I’m hoping that the movie will deliver. I think one of the complexities and I think this speaks to Francis Lawrence’s time behind this franchise. I mean he’s directed all of the films except for the first one. The first one our chronological time being the Hunger Games. He’s directed all of the rest. And we’ll talk about this when we get to the Mockingjay story, but that one was they made the decision to split that into the two films. They almost split this one into two films.
He decided he didn’t want to end up doing that because he felt that it was a really negative experience that he had. Splitting that audiences were very, very frustrated because I mean I struggle through those films because I think they’re the slog. because it’s a it’s a it’s a story that is stretched to fill two long films. And I think it makes it drag tremendously. This, I think, they smartly decided let’s just make a longer film where we’re gonna compress everything into this 158 minutes. And we’re just going to tell the entire story as opposed to splitting it up. And I think that in the long run, I think that was the better decision. Especially thinking that if you think this one was slow, splitting this into two, you have probably an even worse time watching it as two separate films, right?
Pete Wright:
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Although I, you know, I think back And knowing what I had what I discovered in watching this film, I probably should have watched it in thirds, right? Watch each of the of the acts as and just serialize it myself. That probably would have been fine.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah. It’s an it well, and I think to that end, I think that this is also an interesting franchise, and this in particular is an interesting film because It’s a Hunger Games film, but the Hunger Games are really only the first like half of the film. The first two-thirds half to a two-thirds We start with the you know, the mentor part where he you know, all of these students are assigned tributes from each of the districts for the Hunger Games that they have to mentor and try to keep alive and in the process, that’s when he writes this report and presents it to the fantastic Viola Davis, who is brilliant as Doctor Volumnia Gaul. I love her in this film. She’s
Pete Wright:
And it—in a movie of fantastic costume work She’s peak.
Andy Nelson:
She gets some great ones, absolutely.
Pete Wright:
She’s fantastic. Yeah. She is she I mean she represents what these movies become in the costumery, right? I mean it’s fantastic.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, makeup and costume.
Pete Wright:
So
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, no, everything. She’s the head the head game maker and is looking for a way. I mean, this the tenth Hunger Games, and at this point People are getting disinterested because all it is is just throwing people in or into an arena and just watching ’em kill each other. And it’s getting very boring, which is a dark thing to say, but that’s the realities of the way that society starts seeing violence, like this sort of violence, is it just it’s you’re just putting people into an arena to kill each other and it’s like not that It’s dark and it’s kind of disturbing and it’s not that fun to just watch. And so the idea of turning it into an actual entertainment starts at this film.
And this is the point where Snow recognizes that it needs to be something, there needs to be spectacle, and starts drawing that in. And she pulls from his ideas. And they start trying to do more with the games to make them more interesting to get the audiences to start rooting for these people who are in these games. I mean, they’re called games after all, right? It’s not just a gladiator arena. And so I think that’s a really interesting part where we kind of start seeing him putting these pieces together as far as like what to do how to frame all of this, how to actually connect to his tribute, Lucy Gray, which we hadn’t mentioned yet. And of course he’s assigned somebody from District 12 and I think that becomes an interesting element of the story where we’re seeing the setup for all of this. And then part two we jump into the actual the prize where It’s the final competition of it and he’s pushing to get Lucy to win, which of course she does ’cause that’s She kind of wins.
It’s with the cheating that that he ends up doing. Because at this point, Dr. Gaul was just like, you know what, screw them all. I’m just gonna kill every single one of them. I’m done with this whole thing. and kind of wants to wipe him out. But what I find most interesting is that then we end up getting this part three where he ends up getting assigned because they recognize that he’s cheated and he ends up getting assigned to District 12 to go out and work there as a peacekeeper. For me, that was a really interesting element of the story because that’s where now he’s out of District 12. He’s able to kind of continue and develop this relationship with Lucy Gray and meet the coven and everything.
And That’s where things really start shifting for him, as far as like we start getting a sense as to the way that truth can be manipulated and which truths you’re going to tell and everything. And that’s kind of the turn that we end up seeing and the decisions that Coryo ends up making in relationship to his relationship with Lucy Gray that end up shifting all of that into this dark final scene the or sequence that we have between the two of them as they are theoretically gonna go run away. And all of that I think shifts into a very dark place. And I and so I find it fascinating that for a film Where the franchise, especially the first two films, Hunger Games and Catching Fire, are really all about the games, right? Like all the build-up to the games, and then the last half is the games.
And I think no longer are we at a point where the games are the central focus. And I find that to be a fascinating part of this.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, and I think each of those chapters, I mean I struggle the most with the third chapter and I think it’s because I hadn’t I hadn’t bought into the transformation part, the authoritarian part and the movie is insinuating a its push toward Coriolanus Snow’s entire turn to authoritarianism is because of a broken heart. And I didn’t love that. I didn’t love that. I didn’t love her turning on him and leaving in the cabin. The entire third act we called the Coal Miner’s Daughter act because of there’s just a lot of like country western like bluegrass singing in. It just felt very Loretta Lynn to me And then there’s a sequence that reminded me of the Lonely Island sketch, Dear Sister, that where it’s just every time someone comes in the room, someone else gets shot. It’s just kind of lampooning itself.
And I we could I just couldn’t get past some of those sort of stacked dramatic tropes. But the final turn and Tom Blyth gets a chance to really exert some Billy the Kid drama, right? Like he when he’s wandering through the woods and gets bit by that clearly not poisonous snake and has his moment to scream in the woods, that’s acting right there. Like he’s he is he’s really great at being that lost guy in the woods and screaming for her. And if this was in another movie, I think I would have liked it more. I think I would have been able to relate to what Francis was trying to do here with greater affinity.
It did not help that I didn’t connect with Zegler’s performance one iota.
Andy Nelson:
Really?
Pete Wright:
It not a bit. I felt like she was chewing on a snake. Every single word coming out of her mouth. I could not buy her at all. And she’s got a great voice. I didn’t buy it.
Andy Nelson:
She does have a great voice.
Pete Wright:
Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
I mean, she hasn’t been in that much. I mean, what have you are you generally not finding yourself not a fan of her, or is it just this film?
Pete Wright:
Generally not. This film is is probably the most egregious. I didn’t care for her performance in West Side Story. I didn’t care for what was the thing she did before the she’s got she’s got three that I’ve seen. This one, West Side Story, was the third one.
Andy Nelson:
She was in the Snow White, which I’m sure you didn’t see the live action. She was in Shazam, the Shazam sequel, Fury of the Gods.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, I did see that. Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
You did see that. I don’t I don’t know how big her role was in that. And she was in Y2K, so you saw that.
Pete Wright:
Definitely saw that. Yeah. I think I probably liked her best in Y2K.
Andy Nelson:
And then she was in the animated movie Spellbound, so
Pete Wright:
Yeah. So her bigger movies of the movies where she’s singing, she’s great. And this felt like she was a musical theater actor in a movie that wasn’t musical. I didn’t buy the accent not a bit and it took me out of the movie. Every time she was on screen, it took me out of the movie and She’s someone with an extraordinary amount of promise and I can’t wait to see what happens. And this was not the movie that I that I was able to connect with her in.
Andy Nelson:
But it sounds like no movies really have connected with her in. Sounds like she’s a problem for you.
Pete Wright:
Y2K.
Andy Nelson:
Wow.
Pete Wright:
Didn’t care for the I didn’t care for that movie, but
Andy Nelson:
I didn’t think we were gonna be coming to that point in this conversation today.
Pete Wright:
Problematic.
Andy Nelson:
That’s so funny. But Tom Blyth, you like?
Pete Wright:
I do
Andy Nelson:
I feel like I well mostly when you see him, he’s not bleach blonde. Like this, I think, is the very specific for the Coriolanus Snow character. I think the only thing I’ve seen him in, and I don’t wouldn’t have been able to point him out, is because when we talked about Robin Hood, the Ridley Scott Russell Crowe version from 2010, he plays feral child
But that’s the only other thing I’ve seen him in. So I haven’t seen him in much, but I know he’s been I know he’s been starting to kind of pop up and things.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, for sure.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, and I do like that something about this franchise is like they bring in a lot of faces that feel new. Like I mean when I see The Sunrise on the Reaping trailer, I feel like there are some new faces there. And so I think so that also excites me about this. So
Pete Wright:
Yeah, I mean I think so too. And so just litigating a few more things so I can get them out of the way. One of the challenges that faces this movie and this story, I think in particular this movie, is showing how the arena games start. so that they we have lots of room for the arena games to grow, right? And so going back to just an empty arena is hard. This is a heavy lift to try to make this entertaining and put a bunch of kids in this thing and make them go kill each other in a in a way that seems at all interesting. And I think that was a miss in this movie. I did not find myself interested in the actual second chapter, the games themselves. There were a few clever moments, but just having the kids run around in a big broken down arena after an explosion that, and you know, VFX is not my area, but that the bombing of the arena is terrible.
Like it just as an effect, it looks bad. It looks It looks out of time bad. And so I don’t think that did it any favors. By the time we get to the actual production design, the set piece of the arena. I don’t find it a compelling beginning of first ten years of the Hunger Games. I think they’re I think, you know, obviously it’s great that they have a lot of lessons to learn between now and I think the next movie is year fifty. And so there’s a and that’s spectacle. But do you and do you believe that we got to year 50 from this year 10? Maybe you do.
That doesn’t make this year 10 great. Like I just I wasn’t moved by the battle royale part.
Andy Nelson:
You like to see your kids get kill each other with a little more a little more creativity.
Pete Wright:
Pizzazz. A little bit more cleverness.
Andy Nelson:
I gotcha, yeah, yeah, I gotcha.
Pete Wright:
Yeah. They gave him pitchforks. Not one person picked up the bow and arrow. Come on. Are you saving it for Katniss? She doesn’t get there for like 75 years Anyway
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, no well and that’s I think one of the challenges with this film. And certainly the I mean, we’ve talked about it many times, the nature of a prequel and trying to go back and fill in the gaps that got us to where we end up being. And people perpetually will complain about that point with prequels. And I absolutely can see that point here. But I what I guess, I don’t know. I guess for me I find myself able to kind of put myself in that place where this is year ten and I’m enjoying the ideas of what it means for year ten to Try finding a way to change what the games represent and the way that the games are going to be presented. Like I love the all the drones that keep flying in and how They are they are so poorly put together, like that the drones keep like crashing into things and people and then to the point where again This is one of another of Coryo’s cheats that he doesn’t get called out on.
He sends a whole bunch of drones in to attack all of the other players. Just so that Lucy Gray can get away. I thought that was fantastic. And I love that we’re seeing bits of things like that in the film.
Pete Wright:
Yeah. Well, and that that’s what that you just finished my thought. Like that when I say that there’s a lack of cleverness to me in the arena part I did love the origin of the tools, right? Being able to send them water or food by drones that don’t work And then the tour of oddities as they’re walking through her lab and you see him stop at the one with the big bulbous head. It looks like a I don’t know, some kind of weird sperm whale in a jar. I was like that I said out loud, that better be used at some point in this or the next movie.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
I want that to be used.
And the snakes. The snakes were great. The rainbow of destruction. I mean, you know, leaning in a little bit hard on the on the language. The script is pretty flimsy, but the that which may come from the book, like, but casting Peter Dinklage as Highbottom, I just come on. I everybody has a colored name. I just all of the things
Andy Nelson:
That’s the nature of this world though.
Pete Wright:
I know.
Andy Nelson:
Like we’re they’re always like that. Are you saying that they shouldn’t cast Peter Dinklage just because of the character’s name?
Pete Wright:
No, I think it’s just it’s just all Very silly.
It’s just all very silly.
Andy Nelson:
But that’s the that’s this world. Like, do you have you do you remember all the names that we get in the Capitol over the course of this franchise? They’re all silly.
Pete Wright:
I know, I clearly don’t.
Andy Nelson:
That’s what’s so funny about the Capitol. But actually we’re gonna get back to that after a quick break. First, you can find the show on YouTube and you can join us live when we record. We’ll even take your questions in the post-show chit-chat, and members get the full post-show conversation and always know what to listen to next. Subscribe to The Next Reel on YouTube. The link to this episode is in the show notes. We’ll be right back. The Capitol is an interesting world, right? Because clearly it’s a group of people who are very into not just like the wealth and everything that comes with it, but also the class, the nature of class and the status that all of these people have.
I mean we see that constantly with Coryo and all of his classmates. The way that they behave, the way they think, the way they act, the way they treat their tributes, everything I think is is fascinating. And then also the idea of privilege and what it can buy you. And that becomes a big thing. And this will be an interesting point to discuss as we go from this film where we see Tigris, Hunter Schafer’s character, who is Coryo’s cousin. By the time we re-meet Tigris in I can’t remember which of the Mockingjay films, but she’s in them.
Pete Wright:
I have no memory of that. Seriously.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, we’ll meet her again. It’s fascinating to see how people with money, with privilege, start treating their bodies and everything. And we’re gonna see that quite a bit even in the next film because we see that, like the way that Effie, Elizabeth Banks character, the way that she would put on her makeup and her hair and everything, like they really kind of overdo themselves. And they really start like plastic surgery becomes a huge thing and the way that they can manipulate how they look to the point where they start saying I love cats. I think it’s gonna be a great idea if I start manipulating my face to turn into a cat. Like we see that now with some crazy people who are like. I’m gonna make myself look like an actual Barbie doll. It’s like who does that?
Like, I mean, and I think that’s kind of a fascinating element to that these people in the Capitol start kind of seeing as a as a point of position and placement within their world. And so I think that’s going to be an interesting thing to kind of explore as we continue, especially because at this point we’re looking at Coryo who is broke. And starving to the point where his cousin is taking tile off the wall to create fake buttons for his outfits just so he can look like he fits in.
Pete Wright:
Yeah. And I think so much of that, the presentation stuff was the like one of the central sort of cultural critiques that came out of the first set of books, right? Which was like, look at where we’re going. This is so ridiculous. Does anybody really need a Brazilian butt lift? I don’t know the answer to that. You and I maybe do, but that’s not, that’s neither here nor there. The issue is what happens when everybody starts doing it and everybody starts making it a central part of being able to walk outside every day. And that’s I and that’s something that like I guess I lean more toward comfort than what this is critiquing.
And I think that’s central to what the Hunger Games is, is is showcasing the difference that exists or celebrating the history. of the war by way of showcasing our exuberance for fashion and culture, high culture, which is gross.
Andy Nelson:
And yeah, and then on top of that, like everything that goes on between the Capitol and how they view and treat all of the districts. in let’s just say a ranked order, right? Like they like District 2 better than they like District 8 and better than they like District 12. Like there are positions that they have within these different districts that I think speaks to the way that they think about everybody else who is outside the Capitol.
Pete Wright:
Unless, yeah, unless your Grandma’am, who’s just a trope racist sandwich, everyone, her line was everyone outside the Capitol is. Savage. Grandma’am, slow your roll.
Andy Nelson:
Well, but I mean, but why are you saying that? Like are you are you judging her for thinking that way in this in the context of this world?
Pete Wright:
No, in the context of this world, and that this may be a challenge that I have just looking at this material going forward, in the context of this world These presentation this presentation of these characters feels like the simplest, most veneer approach to these characters that could be put on screen. There is a drug that mimics I gather morphine called Morphling. Like, this is the simplest, most veneer approach. To creating a new culture that I could imagine on screen. This movie is a celebration of first thought, best thought. And that’s the problem I have with it. Not that it’s not trying to do something or the other movies don’t do something and have a commentary that’s a little bit better. It’s that this movie is the weakest of the weakest sauce of all of them.
It is the most base approach to talking about racism and cultural admonishment and all of these things, which is which is Kind of the approach of the Hunger Games, I mean, making kids kill each other is the basis argument of, you know, causing pain for a populace to have to watch. But it seems like this movie is the thinnest veiled of it all. It is the simplest excursion into these of any of the movies that of the other movies. And I’m gonna include Mockingjay, but I’m gonna do it provisionally because I know we didn’t like it very much, but I think I like it more than these, than this one.
Andy Nelson:
That’s hard to say. Since you kind of have to wrap it up in two movies instead of the one, you know, and so that I think I think there would have been a version of Mockingjay I would have liked a lot more had it just been one movie. And I think that’s a big frustration that I have with that one.
Pete Wright:
When’s the last time you watched the first that that original series?
Andy Nelson:
Around the time that this was released in theaters. So 2023, I think my daughter and I watched the entire franchise beforehand to prep for this.
Pete Wright:
It’s been much longer for me, so my memory is is definitely faded.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah. It’ll be interesting to revisit them and see just see how they how they feel now And I mean, I do think it’s interesting to take this approach and look at it in Panem timeline to kind of watch the development of this crazy world and see how it changes. So I do think, to your point, I mean, I can understand like there is an element of simplicity to the story and to the way that I think a lot of that falls on Suzanne Collins’ shoulders. the author of the franchise because I mean I think that she started out writing for children’s TV shows, right? Like that’s like Nickelodeon and Nick Jr. and she was working on all that sort of sort of stuff, wrote children’s books. and Scholastic is who published the Hunger Games. Like that blows my mind.
Pete Wright:
No, it is just lunacy.
Andy Nelson:
I mean I get it. I get it that, you know, they really exploded when Harry Potter the books came out. Like that was big for them. But it just seems like for Scholastic press to be putting I mean I used to I mean you probably too do too. Remember in elementary school when you would get the little scholastic book
Pete Wright:
Oh, with the book order form?
Andy Nelson:
the book order form, like every like every quarter and you’d get to pick which books you wanted to get and like I loved that.
Pete Wright:
Yeah. Or Highlights magazine.
Was the Hunger Games on that list for third graders?
Andy Nelson:
And I was gonna say, like, can you imagine The Hunger Games was one of them.
Like, wow.
Pete Wright:
What if the maze on the back of highlights was the Hunger Games arena?
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, right, I know.
Pete Wright:
What if highlights, but the kids all kill each other?
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, so it’s I mean I do think again, I do think that the state of our world allowed for this darker story where kids are killing each other to kind of like to exist in the first place. The popularity, I think, is the thing that really is the surprise. The fact that everybody was just like, oh yeah, let’s watch kids kill each other. That became like such a huge thing. But I and I do see your point about like some elements of simplicity with the way that she tells her stories. But I think that’s just the nature of the beast. And I think it’s that is I mean, we’re gonna see that through all six of these films in What I try to do as I watch that is go, okay, well, what in here is actually like relevant to today’s world?
Because I think she is. Again, even if she is a children’s author, I do think that she is trying to tap into our current state and how things are being shaped in the political arena, in the in the media arena, in what people like to watch on TV, like all of this sort of stuff. I do think that she is actively trying to tap into a lot of that stuff. And I think Francis Lawrence has I mean I mean, as let’s just say Francis Lawrence, who started with Constantine, I mean right out of the gate, he is a filmmaker who is making big spectacle genre films, right? I mean Constantine, I Am Legend, Water for Elephants is the real step out of For him.
Pete Wright:
Yeah
Andy Nelson:
Then he jumps into the Hunger Games movies and finishes Catching Fire of the Two Mockingjays, Red Sparrow, Slumberland, which I’ve missed, and then he does This, The Long Walk, and now Sunrise on the Reaping.
So All he’s done are big spectacle films. And you can argue that in Hollywood, studios like their directors, their storytellers, who are Making these big franchise movies to kind of take those simpler paths, right? It helps you get that four quadrant audience. And I think that will perpetually be an issue that we will see with these films.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, I think about movies that dystopian movies that I prefer and they’re movies like Fury Road, right?
Andy Nelson:
No, no, yeah, I yeah, I get that. Yeah, yeah.
Pete Wright:
You know what I mean? And I think it’s because I think there is there is a story going on that isn’t just pasting the lessons we should learn on it like in paper mache. Like, pay attention to this. This is I’m gonna this is gonna represent drug problems. It’s gonna be so obvious right here because the word even sounds so familiar. Like you’re there will be no question. I don’t feel like this.
And I and I’ll say it because I think you’re leading me into it. I don’t think this story has a lot of trust in me, the reader. We’ll see, because I’m interested in reading it. I have it. I’m ready to read them. And I’d like to get through them quick. And I think part of the challenge that the movies have is that they inherit that simpler approach to the story. And just slap you in the face when it’s time for you to pay attention.
As a result, it ends up being boring because it’s not a very challenging watch. Just intellectually. And so without I think maybe you’re this is you’re doing great work here. What you’ve made me realize is the reason I prefer more pomp and circumstance and more of the vibrance and colors of the games is because the story is so simple, I need something brighter to look at because I’m a child. It did we’ve come all the way back around to scholastic.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, right, right. It’s very funny.
Pete Wright:
I had no idea we’d get there.
Andy Nelson:
Well, to that end, I will say what I think is fascinating, and maybe this is a valuable lens through which to look at these films is they are written for young adults, right? Now, I mean, our children are
Pete Wright:
That’s so crazy.
Andy Nelson:
Well, I know, I know. All of that is just totally bonkers. That aside though, I do think like when I sit down and watch this with my daughter And my son, I feel that because of the way that the stories are being told, they are able to more easily I mean obviously they can connect with the story and everything and the characters, but I think that it’s a good way for them to pull lessons of our modern world in and start seeing things through that lens, you know.
And I think that there is value to these being kind of these big quadrant films that the whole family can go to and have their popcorn while the kids slaughter each other. I think there’s value in just remembering that these are essentially written for young adults.
Pete Wright:
Man. What have what hath we wrought?
Andy Nelson:
I know I know just saying that sounds so wrong.
Pete Wright:
I know. It’s like
Andy Nelson:
But that is that is the there as yeah, it’s a dark world.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, no, I get it.
Andy Nelson:
It’s a dark world.
Pete Wright:
If you could put just a little reverb or a little bounce when you say These are made for kids or young adults. Just make it echo. I want to make sure that’s big. I want to make sure people understand.
Andy Nelson:
People need to understand. People need to know.
Pete Wright:
They need to know.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah. Oh my gosh. Oh my gosh.
Pete Wright:
Yeah
Andy Nelson:
Well, I okay, so I have a good sense of your position with the story, but just a few other points that I just kind of want to get your read on.
Pete Wright:
Yes.
Andy Nelson:
I want to look at how you felt everything played with Coryo and his I don’t know, his friend, his sometimes friend, his not sometimes friend. Sejanus Plinth. That relationship, because Sejanus is from District 2, so they’re very close to the Capitol, to the point where he actually is one of these mentors. yet is absolutely against all of this stuff going on.
And when he and Coryo end up out in District 12, he’s the one who is covertly meeting with the people there trying to get weapons and all the different things that they’re doing, kind of the underground. And he’s Coryo’s friend who Coryo turns the Jabberjays, the little Jabberjay recording devices on to record this conversation that ends up getting him killed. I mean, how do you feel that that relationship plays over the course of the story?
Pete Wright:
I actually think it’s Well the relationship between these two young men is one of the most one of the more interesting relationships in the movie. I think they, you know, he gets an opportunity, Sejanus, to be kind of the bounce card for this kind of Hobbes v. Locke kind of philosophical debate that is going on between these two characters. And that the state of nature tilting toward the good and doing right by the little people is Sejanus’s opportunity to reflect the nature of Snow’s journey, but also of the entire universe, the Panem sort of multiverse. And I like what that represents.
Like I like him in this. He’s an—very important role in the movie because he’s the delicate flower that ends up getting squashed because of his feelings of goodness, right? Because of his bent toward his arc of good, he gets betrayed using the technology of, you know, of hate. And I think that’s I think that’s an important angle. I think the I think he is good at it too. I think both of them are good characters and my I scrolled past my cast list. What was his Sejanus’ name?
Andy Nelson:
Josh Andrés Rivera
Pete Wright:
Yes, I think he was great in this role, and I love his final moment at the hanging tree as he’s just sort of wailing Coryo, Coryo, Coryo, and Coriolanus won’t look at him, I think that’s a very, yeah, a very powerful moment.
Andy Nelson:
And all the birds the birds start doing yeah. Yeah. I think it’s a really interesting relationship as well. And I think it speaks to A lot of kind of the way that Coryo ends up kind of changing and evolving, right? And I think it actually all starts when Sejanus’s tribute gets killed. And he sneaks into the arena late one night to do kind of the District 2 putting a the person to rest sort of thing, the ceremony.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, the ceremony
Andy Nelson:
And Coryo is asked or kind of told to go in and rescue his friend, right? And so he has to go in. He resents it.
He like all of these different things that kind of push him to a place where he sees Sejanus as a friend, but also as a real pain in the ass. And I think that’s what’s interesting because at that point he has to get him out of there. And that’s where he ends up killing one of these tributes, right? And to the point where like it shakes him, but also I don’t think he felt that bad about it, right? Like I think that the change in his head at that point was like, this guy was coming at me. He deserved it. And I think that was an interesting first shift that we see that kind of puts him on this road to the point where he’s kind of okay with Doing this whole little thing with the Jabberjay and getting Sejanus in trouble.
Pete Wright:
Well, that’s the interesting turn too, because at the moment when he kills the first tribute He the rift is I came in to save one of mine and I’m okay killing one of yours to do that, right? And he’s not to the point in his Anakin arc where he’s killing younglings But he kind of is, right? He just killed a youngling.
Andy Nelson:
He just killed a youngling, right?
Pete Wright:
Right? He just isn’t a true believer yet.
Andy Nelson:
Right.
Pete Wright:
But, you know.
Andy Nelson:
It will come.
Pete Wright:
I every everybody has a an arc where they have to kill a youngling in these stories, so
Andy Nelson:
It will come
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
This was it.
But the younglings are legit, right? They’re serious, mad. And that’s one of the things that this movie, I think, gets the levels up in these young performers, they are savage in the way they relate to one another. Generally it’s Savages and Rachel Zegler and the kid with rabies.
Andy Nelson:
I also really liked the I can’t remember what her name was, but the mentor who does nothing but like taunt her poor tribute like, oh want some water?
Pete Wright:
I know. Luckily that doesn’t last too long before she takes a bottle in the neck
Andy Nelson:
Who gets Yeah. That doesn’t last very long. Right. She does not bode yeah, things do not bode well for her.
Pete Wright:
My favorite alt mentor is the young woman who the sycophant who keeps trying to add her name to Coriolanus’s work and ends up getting besnaked.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
That was my favorite, for sure.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, ends up in the hospital. Right.
Pete Wright:
Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
That was great. That was great. I want to go back I just want to go back to one last point that you had mentioned because I can’t help but feel like you end up oversimplifying things a little bit when you say that The reason Coryo changes is because of a broken heart. And I want to talk about that a little bit because I think that there’s a lot more going on in the way that everything unfolds in that last act that isn’t just about a broken heart. I think so much of it is about layers of trust and mistrust and the change in the way that the relationship shifts, right?
And I think that’s what’s fascinating and every single thing between the two of them really from the point where he ends up turning and shooting Lucy Gray’s ex-boyfriend’s new girlfriend. I can’t remember what her name is, the mayor’s daughter. That sounds so Just saying that makes it sound like I’m talking about a soap opera here.
Pete Wright:
I don’t need any help.
Andy Nelson:
I know, I know. I’m digging my own grave, is that what you’re saying here?
Pete Wright:
Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
Anyway, but from the point that he turns and kills that that woman which leads to more of these underground people getting killed. Lucy Gray is starting to kind of like I feel like there’s a hint of mistrust that she’s starting to develop in everything that Coryo represents.
And it all comes to a point when he inadvertently lets slip that that of three is enough for me, is what he says, as far as like how many people he’s killed. And as far as she knows, he’s only killed two
Pete Wright:
Yeah, that’s
Andy Nelson:
And that little shift, you know, because they talk about this, like the nature of trust and the point where trust breaks down. And I think that becomes the element that that really kind of ends up shaping things. And it’s less about the love and the relationship that they have and more about his ambition and his desires and where he sees himself going. over the you know, through kind of the way that the story’s gonna unfold. I don’t know. I’m curious if you see any more to that or if it is just all about all about love, broken hearts.
Pete Wright:
Well, I stand by my comment that he’s that it’s all rooted in a broken heart because I think everything you’ve described the breaking of trust is the breaking of the heart, right? I mean that’s what I mean. I even though I look at that scene where he said she says who was the third And he waits so long while he’s trying to come up with what to say. You can drive a truck. through the gap before he realizes duh the third one was me. I mean, yeah, that’s it. It was me. The original me, yeah?
It just So bad. It’s so poorly directed. I don’t it was a laugh line. And yet, and yet, the beats leading up to that, the discovery of the guns that were in this cabin. the wondering if she actually knew that the guns were in the cabin up front. If she actually had so if she was that’s when that we get this turn from her, right? This is all camera. We have him looking at the gun, we get close-ups on the gun, he picks up the gun. The camera is on the floor.
If it could be through the floor, it probably would. we get these angles looking up at these towering faces of him and his uncertainty and his awareness that now he has a way out, and then to her, where she looks straight up diabolical in this sequence And you realize that there is a level of manipulation coming from her that I don’t think we were intended to see coming. And that is, it all precedes that exchange. about how many people have you killed and it is the moment it is the maybe the only moment in the film. Where subtext is more important than the text, and I really like it. Like apart from how dumb that line is I really like the fact that the movie is trusting me to wonder who’s manipulating whom. It happens pretty late in the film, and I don’t think we get there is no sense of that broken trust happening when he picks up the gun and shoots the mayor’s daughter.
There is no sense that she is she’s just like, oh my God, murder happened and I have to go out and sing a song. And so I think probably we could have used some fracturing of their relationship before the cabin moment, but the cabin moment is aces. I think it’s I think it actually gives us a lot to chew on about these two characters. And it leads up to what I’ve already said is my favorite sequence of the movie, which is Blyth wandering through the snowy woods and getting bit by a snake.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, I do think that it’s a really interesting point in his and this is why I think it works for his development. I mean yes I agree that there is a broken heart, but I do think that there’s more to it than and that’s why I think it’s a little simplistic to just say it’s a broken heart.
Pete Wright:
You must have never loved.
Andy Nelson:
I think that there’s
Pete Wright:
You’ve never loved before.
Andy Nelson:
I’ve never loved.
Pete Wright:
I’m calling your wife.
Andy Nelson:
Okay. But I do think that it also is in context of the world in which they live, I think there’s the there is the breaking of his heart, but I think it ties into everything that’s going on with the position that she has with the coven and the and the position that she has with the underground and the people and the things that she represents and the way that she survives and the way that he sees everything going on in District 12 and now the way that he starts painting District 12 as You know, they’re all kind of conniving and they’re all trying to find ways back at getting back at the Capitol and all of the people who have tried to stop all of this.
And so I think it represents a lot of the shifts that for me end up playing well into kind of his distrust of the districts and particularly District 12, which obviously will kind of continue over this and yeah.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, that pays dividends.
Andy Nelson:
District 12 is always the thorn in snow’s side. But I don’t know. I guess for me I just find that it all works and I really enjoy it.
Pete Wright:
I wonder, I and I couldn’t help but continue to wonder as I was watching this movie last night. what the experience would have been had we watched these in release order, had we just come off of a double feature of Mockingjay Part One and Two, and then gone into this movie. I mean, I don’t know. I didn’t having not watched them in that order, but I think this movie probably would have tested my patience even more. and seemed a little bit more reductive to the story of the young tribute trying to make good in a world of chaos and games. So we you know, and that’s a challenge that I think comes through the books, like trying to take a single concept, this single conceit. and make it not Uber repetitive with every single revisit to the universe is a real challenge of narrative. And I think that generally the books do a pretty good job of that, but this one it feels certainly reflective of the story we’ve seen before with different faces.
Andy Nelson:
Well, that and that’ll be an interesting element to talk about as this series continues. You know, just to see like which ones feel like I mean, yeah, I mean we actually only get like a real just like hunger game finale as kind of like the con the kind of the final act of the film. I think in the well, the first like the Hunger Games, certainly in Catching Fire, although it shifts, things end up shifting at the end of that one. And then I would I’m gonna say Sunrise on the Reaping, I think, is gonna be another one that feel that will feel for you probably like a return to form. Like it’s focused on the games. It’s not about what’s going on outside of the game games, which becomes I mean that’s a whole thing with Mockingjay, which makes it feel so different, right?
Pete Wright:
Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
And this essentially like the last that’s why this one does also share that, I think a little bit, because the last chunk of the film is not about the games.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, right. Well and I think, you know, all things being equal, I like the big swings. I like the fact that there’s narrative going on outside of the games. I’m not I’m not saying that at all. I am saying I think one of the challenges of Mockingjay was probably that we were deep in the dystopian kids you know, period arc of our entertainment and we were dealing with the Divergent series adaptations and the Maze Runner series adaptations and there was a lot going on that we were trying to absorb that was all about kids in trouble and in many respects, this series right now is probably the best time to be thinking about it because we don’t have a lot of competing signal in the same space.
Andy Nelson:
We’re through a lot. Yeah, we’ve gotten through a lot of that. I just also have to call out Jason Schwartzman, who I really love as Lucretius Lucky Flickerman in this as our
Pete Wright:
Andy, I can’t believe that I can’t believe it took this long to say it. You’re absolutely right. He’s the
Andy Nelson:
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
single best the best thing in this movie when he turns to camera and the snakes have been lowered into the arena and he says wouldn’t it be great if it was candy I need I want that to be improv. Please tell me that wasn’t in the book.
Andy Nelson:
I can’t I can’t remember honestly, but
Pete Wright:
I need Schwartzman to have that win. It was so good.
Andy Nelson:
No, I love him. And it’ll be a fun line to kind of follow these people who are the ones who are kind of reporting. Things going on. You know, we certainly see some so Stanley Tucci is great in the latter films, but and I don’t know who we have in the next one. So it’ll be interesting to see.
Pete Wright:
The coins, he keeps he’s a he’s an amateur magician. And he keeps throwing up coins. And I don’t think I ever caught that the coins eventually come down.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, it’s always at the end of his reporting.
Pete Wright:
At the end of his bit.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
Yeah, I think I had never I didn’t catch that the first time I watched it. I it’s brilliant.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, he’s fantastic.
Pete Wright:
Brilliant. Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
All right. Well, oh, and just one last note. You mentioned that you weren’t a fan of like the music and stuff. I love the music. I love that it feels very I mean I don’t know. When you look at kind of the map of what’s left or what Panem is, which is kind of the remnants of the US after this big nuclear war that they had. It’s kind of the Kentucky area, right? Kind of Kentucky, Georgia, that part of the country.
And so I love that they end up tying music in. into this story because I feel like music ends up becoming I don’t know, I think it’s an important element that we I mean we even see through today of how music is memory. Music is protest. Like the way that people can use music, I think, is such a key part of like the art of it, I think is such just a key part of all of those elements of humanity and finding our paths through these sorts of constraints that the Capitol might put on us and a form of resistance. I love that about this entire franchise
Pete Wright:
I feel like answering that question takes me back to my lack of connection to the performer. Who is very polished and very talented. And every time we’re in a singing sequence, it feels like we’re stepping into a different movie.
Andy Nelson:
Do you like that part of the world though?
Pete Wright:
Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
Even if you’re not a fan of the performance.
Pete Wright:
Exactly.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
Exactly.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
Yeah.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
No, I a 100 percent agree. And I think it’s really I mean it’s important. There is something about it that just screams, we have someone with a special ability, and we need to find a way to use it in a way that starts to feel ham-fisted and not natural to the environment. that just it feels out of place in where it should feel of a place. And that’s the that’s my challenge.
Andy Nelson:
That’s interesting. I because it’s written that way, where she is very much like part of the coven and they are performers, and that’s their whole thing. So I think basically the way I’m hearing what you’re saying is the fact that you can’t connect with Rachel Zegler. She sounds too polished and everything makes it feel like it’s not fitting into the world as accurately as it should be.
Pete Wright:
Well, because part of it is that she’s the only one who really sings. Like we have sequences where other people start singing in the crowd and crowd singing happens. But she’s the only gypsy soloist? I just don’t I don’t believe it. I feel like we’re never given a chance to see the coven texture of musicality because she’s the only one who’s really given a chance to star. And I get it, she’s our main character, but if you’re gonna showcase A place that is built on music, we need to have her be subservient to some other performers in principal sequences, also. Have someone sing to her.
Andy Nelson:
That’s the three hour cut, Pete.
Pete Wright:
There are other areas that I can see.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, so when you’re saying you want it longer
Pete Wright:
I want they didn’t make this a trilogy? Are you kidding? There are other areas I would cut to give us more texture in her world because I feel like that’s a missing piece that I could really embrace.
Andy Nelson:
Okay. Well, I say let’s move on to the back half. What do you say?
Pete Wright:
Now let’s do it.
Andy Nelson:
All right, first let’s take a quick break.
Pete Wright:
The Next Reel is a production of TruStory FM, engineering by Andy Nelson, music by Roie Shpigler, Jay Putty, Oriol Novella, and Eli Catlin. Andy usually finds all the stats for the awards and numbers at The-Numbers.com, BoxOfficeMojo.com, IMDb.com, and Wikipedia.org. Find the show and the full archive at TruStory.fm. You can follow us from there too. Plus, you can find out how to become a member and go further with every episode.
Check out our merch store at TheNextReel.com/merch. And if your app allows ratings and reviews, please consider doing that for our show.
Oh, Andy, how do you even begin a sequels and remakes conversation?
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, I think at this point it’s just fair to say we will be talking about all of them in this series. So there will be plenty to discuss over the course of it. And we’ll try, like I said, when we get to the next movie, Sunrise on the Reaping, we’ll talk about if there’s anything planned for afterward.
Pete Wright:
Okay, perfect. How to do it award season?
Andy Nelson:
It wasn’t huge at the award circuits. It had seven wins with 29 other nominations. Over at the Saturn Awards, the Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy and Horror, it was nominated for Best Science Fiction Film but lost to Dune: Part Two. This was an interesting trio of awards. Best young performer in a film, Rachel Zegler, lost to Jenny Ortega in Beetlejuice Beetlejuice. Best Film Music also lost to Beetlejuice Beetlejuice, as did Best Film Costumes I think that’s interesting. I don’t know if I would have given Beetlejuice Beetlejuice any of those awards. But you know what?
Pete Wright:
Yeah, I don’t know that I would have either.
Andy Nelson:
It’s Beetlejuice.
It’s yeah. They’re it’s the Saturn awards. They do crazy things sometimes.
Pete Wright:
It’s Jenna Ortega too, though, right?
Andy Nelson:
Oh yeah, Jenna Ortega. Sorry. Lost to Jenna Ortega.
Pete Wright:
Okay.
Andy Nelson:
And last but not least, Tom Blyth was nominated for best actor in a film, but lost to Nicolas Cage in Dream Scenario. Over at the CSA Awards, the Casting Society of America, it was nominated for the Zeitgeist Award, which honors outstanding achievement in casting for massive, culturally defining blockbusters that capture the spirit of the times. I thought that was an interesting award. Of course it lost to Barbie, which I can certainly see that one.
At the Hollywood Music in Media Awards, it was nominated for Best Original Song. Olivia Rodrigo, the one that plays over the end credits, it won for that. And it was nominated for Best Original Score Sci-Fi Fantasy, but lost to The Marvels. And then the Costume Designers Guild Awards. It was nominated for Excellence in Sci Fi Fantasy Film, but lost to Barbie, and Excellence in Costume Illustration, but lost to Rebel Moon Part One: A Child of Fire. Probably one of the few awards that film. one It’s probably true.
Pete Wright:
I would say one of the few awards that film deserves to win, too.
Andy Nelson:
Probably true, yeah.
Pete Wright:
Like I can say unironically, costumes were dope.
Andy Nelson:
They were great. They were great.
Pete Wright:
All right. How to do at the box office.
Andy Nelson:
Well, for Lawrence’s first prequel, he had a budget of 100 million or 109 million in today’s dollars. After its premiere on November 5th, 2023, the film opened wide November 17th. Here in the States opposite, Trolls Band Together, Next Goal Wins, and Thanksgiving. This opened in the number one spot, which it held for two weeks through the big Thanksgiving holiday weekend before getting bumped by Renaissance: A Film by Beyoncé. While this film had the smallest opening of the franchise, it still did well for itself, going on to earn $166 million domestically and $198 million internationally for a total gross of $215.4 million in today’s dollars. Even with its length as the longest film in the franchise up to this point, it still lands with an adjusted profit per finished minute of 1.8 million. That’s a pretty good spot to land for this prequel.
Pete Wright:
It is. It’s a fine spot to land. It is a good swing that I didn’t care for, and I’m still excited to see the next one.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I’m very I love this film. It’s my favorite of the films that I’ve seen thus far of this franchise. I mean I mean there’s never a huge Hunger Games fan to begin with. So maybe I was just looking maybe I was just looking for something that did something different, you know.
Pete Wright:
But this one did it for you?
Andy Nelson:
And so I think that’s that, you know, this one I just really connected with. So All right, well that is it for our conversation about The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.
Next week we are moving forward in Panem’s timeline to the 50th Hunger Games. with The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, just in theaters. This is the Second Quarter Quell, the one that raised the stakes on everything, and it follows a teenage Haymitch Abernathy long before he became the drunk mentor we met in the original films. Francis Lawrence is back in the director’s chair, so we get to see how this world looks when it isn’t about Coryo. And now let’s do our ratings.
Pete Wright:
Letterboxd.com/thenextreel. That’s where you can find the HQ page on the Letterboxd, which is where we rate and review all of the films across the Next Reel family of film shows. Andy, what are you gonna do with your stars and hearts? You’re gonna take stars away from other movies.
Andy Nelson:
I will just to bump it up, since I know you’re probably going super low, but I mean
Pete Wright:
Okay
Andy Nelson:
I have always given this four stars on a heart, and I feel like that’s still where I’m going to sit. And I think it’s largely because I mean I love this movie. It still is in kind of this Hunger Games world. I mean I could go to four and a half. I feel okay sitting at four. That’s where I’ve always been with this one.
Pete Wright:
I came in really wondering if I mean I’m not gonna watch this movie again. I it is the weakest of the batch for me, but I don’t have the recency that you do, so we’ll see. You did sway me a bit though, and so I’m gonna bump it up to two stars.
Andy Nelson:
Look at that.
Pete Wright:
I know. Look at that.
Andy Nelson:
Two stars and I’m assuming no heart.
Pete Wright:
I didn’t give it a heart, no.
Andy Nelson:
All right. Well that will average out to three stars and a heart, which you will find on our Letterboxd account @thenextreel. You can find me there @sodacreekfilm and Pete @petewright. So what did you think about The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes? We would love to hear your thoughts. Hop into the Showtalk channel over in our Discord community where we will be talking about the movie this week.
Pete Wright:
When the movie ends
Andy Nelson:
Our conversation begins.
Pete Wright:
Letterboxd giveth, Andrew.
Andy Nelson:
As Letterboxd always doeth.
Pete Wright:
Okay. This was this was harder for you, it seems like. This was a struggle to find one that really Chef’s kiss perfect.
Andy Nelson:
I you know I liked I actually liked quite a few of them, but there are a lot of them. that are very popular. And so I was trying to go, well, I don’t want to pick the most popular one. So that was my struggle. How where how did you go? What was your
Pete Wright:
I went low because I wanted to see what was going on at the bottom of the barrel. And the one that I picked is less a critique of the movie than it is a reminder of another line that I wanted to make sure that you and I talked about because I thought it was really speaking of Chef’s kiss, perfect. Can I can I go This is a half star from henrylaz who says at one point during this movie
Andy Nelson:
No.
Pete Wright:
Viola Davis says that she’s going to go eat milk and crackers. As it that’s all of you.
Viola Davis was chewing the crap out of this movie.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah.
Pete Wright:
She is the she definitely got bit besides Lucky Flickerman.
Andy Nelson:
See, it’s clearly having fun.
Pete Wright:
Viola Davis may be the MVP of this movie.
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, she’s fantastic.
Pete Wright:
Milk and crackers.
Andy Nelson:
I mean graham crackers, if they’re graham crackers. But if it’s like a saltine
Pete Wright:
She doesn’t say graham crackers. This could be saltines, milk and saltines
Andy Nelson:
Yeah, welcome Ritz?
Pete Wright:
Or those like barley crackers that are the size and texture of a coaster.
Andy Nelson:
Like what
That’s the only way to eat those, man.
Well, my I went with three stars by giselle.
Pete Wright:
All right, what do you got?
Andy Nelson:
who says the whole movie exactly the same, but instead of his nickname being Corio, they just call him Anus.
Oh, I thought you’d appreciate that one.
Pete Wright:
I can’t even
The hanging tree Anus Anus Anus Anus Anus Ah Anus
Andy Nelson:
Huh?
Pete Wright:
God, thanks, Letterboxd