Subscribe to the show in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or anywhere else you find your favorite podcasts!
My Bloody Valentine • Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast • Episode 609

My Bloody Valentine

Love bites and so does Famine! Join hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor from Mesa’s Neighborhood Comedy Theater as they dive into one of Supernatural‘s most disturbing Valentine’s Day episodes. This chunky episode serves up body horror with a side of burgers as the Winchester brothers face off against the Horseman Famine in a tale that makes cannibalism look like romance gone wrong.

The Feast of Famine

Our hosts break down how Famine’s hunger-inducing powers affect everyone differently—from couples literally consuming each other to Castiel’s newfound obsession with hamburgers. The episode brilliantly shows Dean’s emotional emptiness through his immunity to Famine’s effects, while Sam’s demon blood addiction becomes the key to victory. It’s a masterclass in character development disguised as monster-of-the-week horror.

Drinking Game Carnage

This episode proved to be a heavy drinking game with rules including drinks for “Smooch City” moments, Dean’s drinking, deaths (double if named), demon smoke, Cupid hugs, Sam questioning Dean, the word “hungry,” and every time Castiel eats. The hosts hilariously disagreed on counts, with Krissy tallying 18 instances of “hungry/hunger” compared to Nate’s 8, proving this episode was as packed with content as Famine’s victims were with food.

Other Topics Covered:

  • Russell and Alice’s disturbing opening scene
  • Office romance gone murderous with Jimbo, Brad, and Janice
  • Dr. Corman’s memorable performance and tragic end
  • Cupid’s emotional breakdown and revelation about the Winchester parents
  • The grotesque Biggerson’s restaurant massacre
  • Sam’s demon blood relapse and heroic demon exorcism
  • Dean’s existential crisis about his inner emptiness
  • Castiel’s burger addiction and raw hamburger consumption

Next Episode Preview: Season 7 Episode 19 “Of Grave Importance” featuring Bobby as a ghost with drinking rules for ghost appearances, Swayze references, and Bobby’s signature phrases.

Find Gank That Drank wherever podcasts are downloaded, and catch Krissy and Nate live at the Neighborhood Comedy Theater in downtown Mesa, Arizona!

Welcome to Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast! It’s the podcast where two comedians create drinking game rules for some of our favorite episodes of our favorite show: Supernatural. In each episode, we make up drinking game rules and then recap the episode to see how the rules played out. At the end, we make up new rules for the next episode! Join us for laughs, ganks, dranks, and more!
Scroll To Top