We cover Season 9, Episode 7, “Bad Boys”—building a drinking game companion to the Supernatural episode where a mysterious call pulls Dean back to a boys’ ranch in upstate New York.

We dive into Season 9, Episode 6, “Heaven Can’t Wait”—the one where a newly human Castiel is living his best (and most mundane) life working a gas station convenience store.

We crack open Supernatural Season 7, Episode 4, “Defending Your Life”—the one where Sam and Dean chase a string of mysterious deaths where victims are being punished by their own dark pasts.

We take on Season 8, Episode 18, “Freaks and Geeks”, where Sam and Dean roll into a small town on a vampire case and find a team of teenage hunters already working the same nest.