We cover Season 8, Episode 6, “Southern Comfort,” of Supernatural. When violent deaths hit Kearney, Missouri, Sam and Dean arrive to find a familiar hunter already on the case.

We pour our way through Season 10, Episode 12 of Supernatural, “About a Boy,” a case where a string of disappearances keeps ending the same way: a flash of light and an abandoned hex bag.

We cover Season 9, Episode 7, “Bad Boys”—building a drinking game companion to the Supernatural episode where a mysterious call pulls Dean back to a boys’ ranch in upstate New York.

We dive into Season 9, Episode 6, “Heaven Can’t Wait”—the one where a newly human Castiel is living his best (and most mundane) life working a gas station convenience store.