Most of the questions in this mailbag are asking for a line. The day the scale stops being water and starts being fat. The weight that counts as heavy when you’ve never picked one up. Some of those lines exist. There is a protein number, and the two figures that circulate online sit almost threefold apart because they answer different questions. There is a standard creatine dose, and independent labs have tested whether the gummies in your feed contain it. And soreness after pickleball is telling you something, just probably not what you hope.

Then there are the questions the earlier episodes skipped: what recovery looks like for a nurse who works three nights a week and flips back to days, and what a total beginner with a downloaded program and no coach should treat as a red flag. There’s a refeed day explainer in here too, and a list of what to watch in the first three months, when the scale isn’t trustworthy and the mirror hasn’t caught up.

Also in this one: an apparent contradiction about evening workouts and sleep gets settled, and research on metabolism between ages 20 and 60 that most people get wrong.

Links & Notes

Pete Wright:
Welcome to Build for Health, the show that redefines strength, because muscle isn’t just for looks. I’m Pete Wright, and I’m here with Coach Srdjan Injac, and today is Listener Question Day.

Srdjan, how you doing? Are you ready for Listener Question Day?

Srdjan Injac:
I’m doing great. Yes, I love the questions.

Pete Wright:
Oh, I love it.

Srdjan Injac:
I encourage it. The more questions, the better.

Pete Wright:
Yeah, the more questions, the better. We’ve got a doozy of them today. A doozy. Apparently that’s how I measure things now, in bundles of doozies. Okay, it’s been a day.

Let’s start with Marcus’s question. Marcus writes, “Okay, so if the scale jump is mostly water, how long until it’s real? Like if I’m still up three pounds on day five, is that fat now?” We did math last time around, and we had calorie math.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah.

Pete Wright:
This was from last week, two weeks ago, something. It’s pretty recent. Give us a refresher course on when it turns to fat.

Srdjan Injac:
Well, first of all, there’s no scientifically established five-day rule that separates water weight from fat gain. So don’t confuse the length of time you’re holding on to weight with the type of weight that you’re holding on to. You can hold water for five days, seven days, or even longer, depending on what caused it. And yes, you can actually gain body fat over a few days if you eat in a significant calorie surplus.

Pete Wright:
Significant calorie surplus, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
Yes, significant. Both things can happen at the same time. But just to put things in perspective, like we talked about before, gaining three pounds of body fat would generally require roughly 10,500 calories above your body’s energy needs.

So that’s a substantial surplus. Fat gain happens when you’re constantly consuming more energy than your body uses over time. But water retention is a completely different process, and water cannot turn into fat.

Also, you need to know that your weight can fluctuate for several days, not just because of water retention. It can also be hormones, inflammation, sodium, carbs, digestion. There are so many other reasons. So don’t overreact to just one weigh-in.

Just give your body time. Look at your weight over two to three weeks. Weigh yourself under consistent conditions, and remember that the scale is giving you a number, not the whole story.

Pete Wright:
Mm-hmm.

Srdjan Injac:
All right? So just keep that in mind.

Pete Wright:
Well, we got a number of questions about weighing. I think people are thinking about weigh-ins an awful lot, probably more than is necessary.

Srdjan Injac:
Than they probably should, yeah.

Pete Wright:
Right. This one comes from Jen in Beaverton. “Srdjan said, ‘Don’t weigh yourself over the holidays.’ But I weigh myself every morning and it’s the thing that keeps me accountable. Is the advice actually to stop weighing, or just to stop freaking out about the number?”

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, just stop freaking out about that number.

Pete Wright:
I think, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
Like I said, it doesn’t give you the whole story. It just gives you that one number, and then people freak out about that number.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
I mean, if it’s keeping you accountable and it works for you, then great.

Pete Wright:
Awesome.

Srdjan Injac:
Keep doing that. A lot of people don’t like that. They freak out. So as long as she knows what those numbers are and how they fluctuate, it’s okay if she wants to keep doing that. That’s great if it helps her and keeps her accountable.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. The question for Jen is, Jen, do you freak out when you weigh yourself every day?

Srdjan Injac:
Yes.

Pete Wright:
If you freak out, then you should stop weighing yourself every day.

Srdjan Injac:
You should probably stop.

Pete Wright:
But it sounds like you’re fine.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah.

Pete Wright:
All right.

Srdjan Injac:
Just so you know, people see the number and they right away think it’s fat.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
There are so many things it can be. So that’s why I’m like, don’t weigh yourself. Do it if it keeps you accountable, maybe every Monday, once a week.

Pete Wright:
Yeah, right. I like to wait. If I’m up, I just stand in front of the mirror and try to flex things that used to be soft and feel like, I’m sure it’s muscle. I’m sure it’s not fat. I’m just sure it’s muscle. It’s okay. Everything’s fine.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, and put your pants on. See if you can button up, or maybe you can’t button up.

Pete Wright:
That’s my little calming meditation.

Right. Yeah, if you can’t button up, I found the fat.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, I even know where it’s at. Right there.

Pete Wright:
Right. Okay. Rob has written in and says, “You said one pound.” Okay. All right, Rob. You and I are kindred spirits. Here we go. “You said one pound a year isn’t a big deal, but I’m 54 and I’ve been gaining a pound or two a year since I was 30. That’s 40 pounds.

“When does it stop being nothing? And is there anything about being older that changes the math Srdjan laid out?” Okay. I think Rob has a sense of humor.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, I know. I mean, you’re absolutely right. A pound or two a year might not seem like much, but over 20, 30 years, yeah, it adds up. So the problem isn’t gaining one pound. It’s allowing that gradual weight gain to continue year after year without doing anything, without making any adjustments.

And yes, age does change things. It changes everything. We tend to lose muscle mass, become less active, and burn fewer calories as a result. Metabolism slows down. Hormone changes can also affect how our body stores fat. But the basic math of calories in versus calories out doesn’t change.

That’s why resistance training, maintaining the muscle mass, staying active, and adjusting your nutrition as you age is important.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So the goal isn’t to wait until you gain those 30, 40 pounds.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
It’s recognizing the trend every year and making those small adjustments.

Pete Wright:
Well, everything you’re talking about smashes headlong into the fact that we get older, we need fewer calories, we burn fewer calories, our metabolism changes, and we typically eat the same amount that we did, or more than we did, when we were 25, right?

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, yeah.

Pete Wright:
The portions can change. We need less to get through the day. And maybe that’ll have something to do with it. It’s math.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, but then because you’re losing the muscle mass, now you have to focus on your protein intake more than you probably did before.

Pete Wright:
Yep.

Srdjan Injac:
Because in your twenties you probably moved a lot more than you’re moving now, too.

Pete Wright:
Right.

Srdjan Injac:
You were spending a lot more energy back then than now. And then of course the muscle mass goes down, and you’ve got to make sure you’re eating that adequate protein intake so you can retain as much muscle mass as possible. And then you’ve got to use them. You’ve got to do some resistance training. So it changes.

Pete Wright:
Okay.

Srdjan Injac:
You actually have to put in more work as you’re getting older.

Pete Wright:
We’ve got an anonymous question. Anonymous writes, “Refeed day. Explain. Is that just a cheat meal, or is there something more to it? Thanks.”

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, I realize I mentioned that a few times, but I never really went into it.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
And what it means, because I don’t think it’s really that important for people who are just losing weight. But the refeed day is different from a cheat meal. A cheat meal is usually about enjoying food that you wouldn’t normally eat. But a refeed day is a planned increase in calories, primarily from carbs, that’s spread out throughout the entire day rather than just one meal.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So the whole purpose is to replenish the muscle glycogen stores, support training performance, and give your body and mind kind of a temporary break from dieting. This is popular with competitors.

For them, especially bodybuilders preparing for a show, a refeed day can be useful because they’re often in such an aggressive calorie deficit, training hard and trying to maintain muscle mass while reaching extremely low body fat levels. But for the average person who is simply trying to lose 10, 20, 30 pounds, refeed days usually aren’t necessary. They can help psychologically, making dieting more sustainable. But they also don’t magically reset your metabolism or speed up fat loss.

And something else important to know is that having a refeed day doesn’t necessarily mean you’re going to ruin your progress. For example, say you’re eating 500 calories below maintenance for six days.

So you’ve created this 3,000-calorie deficit. And you eat at maintenance on your refeed day. You still finish the week with that 3,000-calorie deficit, meaning you can continue losing body fat. You might notice the scale going up temporarily afterwards, and that’s often from the increase in those glycogen stores and the water retention that comes with it. So it’s not necessarily fat gain. That’s what I mean when I say refeed day.

Pete Wright:
Okay. Yeah, you’re eating carbs. You’re not necessarily going out and devouring a whole strawberry shortcake.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, it’s not like you really need it.

Pete Wright:
Okay. Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, you can have the refeed day once a week.

Pete Wright:
Yeah, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
I mean, if it helps you. Because it’s hard for people to stay in that deficit and on that diet perfectly, to be so strict about it. Sometimes they need a little break.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
It helps them mentally.

Pete Wright:
Yeah, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So I’m like, that’s fine, you can do it. Just don’t overeat now. Just get to that maintenance level and you’ll feel good.

You’ll feel full.

Pete Wright:
What’s your routine on refeed day? Do you find you need to work in refeed days right now, or is your routine pretty set?

Srdjan Injac:
Well, my everything is pretty set, so I don’t feel like I need a refeed day. I don’t really have a goal. I’m not competing.

Pete Wright:
You’re not competing for anything right now.

Srdjan Injac:
Or getting ready for a photo shoot or summer or anything like that.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
But when I do that, then yeah, I’ll have refeed days about maybe once a week, once every two weeks. And it does help. I can see a difference, but that’s because I’m going below 10 percent body fat. So I need that.

Pete Wright:
Yeah, right, right.

Srdjan Injac:
It’s not easy, yeah.

Pete Wright:
Serves a purpose. Yeah. And your system already has a place for all those carbs to go, right? That’s the point.

Srdjan Injac:
Yes, because I’m still putting in all the hard work.

Pete Wright:
You’re fine.

Srdjan Injac:
I’m still doing my cardio. I’m lifting heavy weights and I’m still being active.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
That doesn’t change.

Pete Wright:
So let’s talk about heavy weights. Angela writes, “What does heavy mean for someone who has never lifted? Srdjan kept saying heavy is relative. Relative to what? How do I know I found it?” I love this question.

Srdjan Injac:
Well, when I say heavy is relative, I mean relative to your own strength and ability.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
What’s heavy for a beginner might be a warm-up for somebody who’s been lifting for years.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So how do you know you found the right weight?

Pete Wright:
Look, I’ve been training with you for too long to have only just realized this is what you were doing to me. But we had an awakening about a month ago, where you told me each set to pick the weight that would allow me to do X number in that set. And if I can only get to six or eight, that tends to be a heavy set. And if I can do 12 to 15, that might be a normal set. And that totally changed the way I think about picking the weight that I’m pushing or pulling when I’m in the gym, especially when you’re not around. It has been so useful to be able to reframe what my gauge is for success.

So useful. Now you go.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, that’s why I don’t give you the number. I give you the weight, and usually people are like, “Well, how many do you want me to do?”

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
Well, how many can you do? I don’t want to give you 10 or 12, because once I do, you’re kind of limiting yourself. You’re setting that number in your head and that’s all you’re going to do. And probably you’re going to stop and feel like you can’t do any more. But if I say, “Give me at least 10,” now you have room to do more if you can. So I want to see how many times you can actually lift, say, 60 pounds.

Are you going to stop at 10, 12, 15? If you can go more, that means, okay, this is too light for you.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
We can go heavier. If you can’t do six with good form, well, that’s a little bit too heavy now. I don’t want you to get hurt.

But then you also have to look at some other things. For example, six reps doing your lat pulldowns is fine. You’re working on a heavy set, you’re working on strength. But I would never put that much weight on a bicep curl, which is a smaller muscle.

So you have to look at the muscle size. With the smaller muscles, you don’t want to put on so much weight that you can only do six reps. On the pulldown, the back is such a bigger muscle. It can push and pull more weight, so six is fine. It’s okay, as long as you do it with good form. So you have to look at that too.

Pete Wright:
You said the other day, though, and I think you said this offhandedly…

Srdjan Injac:
We talked about…

Pete Wright:
You said, “Sometimes when I’m pushing heavy, I’ll do enough weight that I can only do two.” Is that still a workout?

Srdjan Injac:
Well, I go a little more extreme.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
I wouldn’t recommend that for beginners, definitely. When you’re a beginner, try to keep it to a weight where you can do 10 with good form. You’re aiming for about 10 to 12 reps.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
The first few should feel manageable, and the last two or three should be challenging without sacrificing form. So if you finish 12 reps and could easily do another five to 10, then the weight is too light.

Pete Wright:
Too light, okay.

Srdjan Injac:
For beginners, I recommend choosing a weight that leaves about one or two reps in reserve. So you don’t have to push every time to failure, where you can’t move.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
You can keep one or two in reserve, making sure that you’re not pushing too much, you’re not sacrificing form, you’re not going to get hurt. You’re still going to get the same results.

That’s why. You just want to be safe.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

So we’re not thinking about going so heavy we can only do two now.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, and as the years go on, as you get stronger, you can gradually increase the weight.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. Okay.

Deborah writes in, “Hi Pete and Srdjan, I’m 49, perimenopausal, and I’m the woman Srdjan described who came in before it happens. I’ve been lifting for about a year now. My question is about protein. He mentioned adequate protein a few times during the menopause section, but never said a number. I’ve seen everything from 0.8 grams per kilo to one gram per pound of body weight online, and I know that’s exactly the social media noise you guys were complaining about the week before. So what does Srdjan actually tell his clients, and does it change with menopause?” I like that our reputation is subtly being branded as those who complain about social media.

Srdjan Injac:
I love it.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
I love that.

Pete Wright:
What do you think?

Srdjan Injac:
So it’s a good question. For men who are lifting weights, and for women lifting weights, especially during perimenopause and menopause, I generally recommend 0.8 to 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight daily. So if you weigh 150 pounds, that’s roughly 120 grams of protein a day. At least. If you can eat more, please do.

During perimenopause and menopause, estrogen levels begin to fluctuate and eventually decline. And that can affect muscle maintenance, recovery, bone density, and how your body stores fat as well.

As we get older, we also become somewhat less responsive to the muscle-building effects of protein, a process called anabolic resistance. This means our muscles may need a stronger stimulus from resistance training and adequate protein to maintain or build muscle. So that’s why I encourage women to prioritize strength training and spread their protein intake throughout the day, ideally getting at least 25 to 30 grams, I would say, per meal. More if possible, but at least that, just so you’ll be able to activate protein synthesis, because 25 grams of protein is going to get you about 2.5 grams of leucine. That’s the amino acid that’s responsible for protein synthesis.

So yeah, menopause doesn’t mean you suddenly need twice as much protein, but maintaining the muscle becomes a little bit more challenging, yes. That makes protein and resistance training even more important. You have to prioritize those two. And remember, the goal isn’t to maintain your weight. It’s to preserve muscle mass, strength…

Pete Wright:
Right, right.

Srdjan Injac:
…bone health, and metabolism as you get older, because it slows down.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. Okay.

Srdjan Injac:
So yeah, that’s what I would recommend, what I tell my clients.

Pete Wright:
Okay.

Kathy writes in, “Pickleball is cardio. Fine.” There’s more. “But I play four days a week and I’m sore after every session. If I’m sore, isn’t something getting worked? Why doesn’t that count?” Oh, Kathy. Poking the dragon.

Srdjan Injac:
Oh, I know.

Pete Wright:
Poking the dragon with this question.

What do you got?

Srdjan Injac:
It counts, but I don’t know what her goal is there. Pickleball counts towards what? Muscle gain?

Pete Wright:
Well, no. Okay, context. I’m just guessing now, but I think this is based on our conversation where you said something about pickleball being cardio, and that it’s not going to give you the same benefits as working your systems through resistance training. And now I’m reading into Kathy’s question, but Kathy is saying, okay, fine, pickleball’s cardio, but if I’m sore, doesn’t that mean I’m getting some benefits that cross over into the benefits I get from resistance training?

Srdjan Injac:
Well, pickleball counts as physical activity, and you’re definitely working your muscles, but muscle soreness doesn’t necessarily mean you’re building muscle or getting stronger. Since you’re playing four days a week, I’m sure your body has probably adapted to those movements, but you’re also repeatedly stressing the same muscles, tendons, and joints every day, all the time. All that stopping, starting, lunging, and changing directions can create repetitive stress, especially if you’re not allowing enough time to recover as well.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
That could also explain why you’re consistently sore, rather than it being a sign of muscle growth. Because it’s great for cardiovascular health, coordination, agility, and muscle endurance, but it doesn’t provide the same progressive resistance needed to maximize strength and muscle growth.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So your muscles adapt to the demands you place on them. And playing pickleball four days a week doesn’t necessarily mean those demands are increasing. The difference is that being active isn’t the same as strength training. Pickleball is great and I encourage you to keep playing, but adding maybe two days of resistance training with that would help build strength, maybe also protect her joints, and potentially improve her performance on the court.

And she might even feel less sore, actually.

Pete Wright:
Add those on days you’re probably not playing pickleball hard.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah. And add some rest days, recovery days. She’s not recovering if she’s doing four days in a row.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
I mean, her body doesn’t really have much time to recover. So she’s constantly sore. We talked about how important recovery is as well.

Pete Wright:
Right. Yeah, right, right.

Srdjan Injac:
Not just getting in there and lifting weights and doing all this stuff, being active. Recovery is important.

Pete Wright:
Okay. We’ve got another anonymous question here.

“I really liked the social media one, but I’m going to push back a little. Srdjan said all programs are basically fine. Just pick one and stick with it. That’s easy for him to say. I’m a total beginner. How do I tell the difference between a program that’s fine and a program that’s going to hurt me? He also said he looks at people’s downloaded programs and swaps out exercises because of their bad shoulder or whatever. I don’t have a Srdjan.

“What are the red flags I could look for myself?” We all need a pocket Srdjan.

Srdjan Injac:
I know, I wish I was there to help her.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
It’s hard, because people don’t really know what to look for, and it’s easier for me to look through and pick some stuff and change things, and I do that all the time. If she has someone there who can look through it and show her, that would be great. But the thing is, if you’re doing a program and it’s hurting your joints, your knees, your lower back, or whatever, just stop doing it. It’s not the right program for you. And especially if that workout program doesn’t give you an alternative.

If it doesn’t modify the exercise, if it doesn’t say, “Hey, if you cannot do this, do this,” or “try it this way,” or “switch to this,” then maybe it’s not for you. Maybe it’s a little bit more advanced. Maybe you need to find something more for beginners. But yeah, it’s hard, because there are so many different programs out there, and yes, you try to pick one. And then after a day or two, see if you’re really overly sore in certain muscle groups.

You just have to find somebody who actually knows what they’re doing to help you out with that, because it’s really hard. I mean, I would love to see that program, if there’s any way that you can contact me and send me an email and just give me the list of exercises.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. Send it or come into the gym. Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
And I can respond and just tell her and help her with that.

Pete Wright:
But I think you said it. As a total beginner, you tell the difference between a program that’s fine and a program that hurts you by starting really easy, easier than the program says, and seeing if it hurts. If it hurts, stop doing it.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah.

Pete Wright:
That is really great advice that I think a lot of us take for granted.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, because people think they’re just going to push through it, because the program tells them to do it and you have to do it.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. “If it doesn’t hurt, it’s not working.” Yeah, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah. So just don’t do it. Find another program. Well, that’s painful.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. Well, and that’s a thing we have talked about before, which is the right kind of pain. Because there’s a difference between acute injury pain and soreness that comes a day or two later.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah.

Pete Wright:
That grows very familiar, and that’s the one you’re looking for. Any pain that you’re having in the moment is not the right kind of pain.

Srdjan Injac:
No, no. And it’s hard for people to modify that exercise right there. Maybe she did that exercise last week and it was fine.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
And then this week, for some reason, it hurts. So you’ve got to look at your form also.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
You’ve got to figure out what you’re doing wrong and know how to adjust, but when you’re beginning, you don’t really know how to do that, so it’s hard.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

“What am I supposed to be looking at during these three months to know it’s working? If I’m not supposed to trust the scale and I can’t see anything in the mirror yet, what is the signal?”

Srdjan Injac:
I mean, you can start tracking your progress from the beginning, and progress isn’t always visible in the mirror or on a scale. Are you getting stronger? Are you lifting heavier weights, doing more repetitions, recovering faster between workouts? Are exercises that were difficult a month ago now easier? How’s your energy level, your endurance, and just overall fitness? Are you sleeping and eating better? I always say you’ll feel it before you see it.

You can also track your body measurements and how your clothes fit. Progress pictures are great every few weeks. The scale is still useful, but it’s just one piece of information, and like I said, it doesn’t show you the whole story, the whole picture. You might be gaining muscle, so you can still see that number on the scale going up, and people don’t like that. But you might be losing fat at the same time. That’s why I usually don’t like the scale, unless you have an InBody like here, and then I can measure your body fat, muscle mass, everything.

Pete Wright:
Right.

Srdjan Injac:
And the biggest signal is whether your body is adapting to the work that you’re putting in. Everyone’s a little bit different, but you’re going to feel that.

The first three months also depend on how strict you are, how consistent you are. It might happen in three months. You might not see anything yet, because maybe your diet’s not really on point every day and every week, so it might take a little bit longer. But you’re definitely going to know, because you’re going to feel different.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. Yeah.

I’d like an answer to this question before I’ve started doing anything. And I think you just said it. If you start doing something, you will know when it happens, because you will feel better when you’re doing these exercises in a month and in three months. You’ll notice because your capability changes, even if it doesn’t change on the scale.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah.

Yeah, exactly.

Pete Wright:
Yeah, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
People always ask me when they come in, “Oh, can I do this in three months? In six months?” I’m like, I don’t know. It all depends on you. I can only show you how and tell you the way to do it, but you still are the one who has to do it.

Pete Wright:
You must open the door. Yeah. Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So realistically, for you it might happen in three months. For somebody else it could be eight months. It could take them a year.

Pete Wright:
Rachel has written in and said, “Srdjan said creatine is a thumbs up, and that was the whole discussion. Can you go a little longer into that? Who should take it? How much? Is it different for women? Does it make you hold water? Does it matter when you take it? I’m a 44-year-old mom and every supplement ad on my feed is now creatine gummies, and I’m suspicious.”

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, we talked about creatine once, but…

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
I’ll mention it again.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So creatine is one of the most, like we said, researched supplements out there. And it’s one I recommend to everyone, every healthy adult. The standard dose is five grams of creatine monohydrate daily, and women don’t need a different formula or dosage than men.

And yes, creatine can cause some water retention, but that water is primarily stored inside your muscles, not under your skin. That’s why you might see the scale go up a couple of pounds without actually gaining body fat. As far as timing, it really doesn’t matter when you take it. Consistency matters more than timing.

As long as you take it every day. Maybe at the beginning, don’t take it in the evening closer to bedtime, because sometimes it can give you a little energy. Some people feel like they’re getting energy and they have a hard time sleeping. And you don’t need a loading phase or anything fancy.

About those gummies that you’re seeing everywhere, I would be skeptical too. Some may contain adequate creatine, but others have small doses and then added sugar, or just questionable quality.

Pete Wright:
So much sugar, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, they’re very questionable. The quality.

So I would stick with plain creatine monohydrate powder from a trusted, third-party-tested company. They’re inexpensive, effective, and very well studied. So I would kind of stay away from some of the gummies. I would actually have to look at the label and do a little research on the brand.

Another interesting thing about creatine is that about 95 percent of it is stored in our muscle, like we said, while the remaining five percent is found in other tissues, including your brain. So that’s why creatine is very important. Our bodies naturally produce creatine, and we also get it from foods like meat and fish.

But as we get older, our muscle creatine storage kind of declines, partly because we tend to lose muscle mass and become less active. So that’s another reason creatine supplements, especially combined with resistance training, can be beneficial as we’re aging. It’s great for our brain health as well, and memory too.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So yeah, definitely.

Pete Wright:
Okay.

Srdjan Injac:
Take creatine.

Pete Wright:
Creatine’s good. All right.

Srdjan Injac:
Yes.

Pete Wright:
Melissa R. writes in, “I’m a night shift nurse.” Oh, I can already see where this is going. Oh my God.

Srdjan Injac:
Yep, I know.

Pete Wright:
“7 p.m. to 7 a.m., three nights a week, then I flip back to a normal schedule on my days off.

“Everything in the sleep episode assumed a normal day. I lift on my off days and I’m trying to figure out whether I’m wasting my time. Is there any version of recovery that works when your sleep schedule is a mess because of work? Pete said, ‘Talk to a specialist if you have a disorder.’ I don’t have a disorder. I just work nights.” What do we do? How do we help Melissa?

Srdjan Injac:
You’re absolutely not wasting your time lifting weights. Even with the irregular sleep schedule, resistance training still provides benefits for muscle mass, strength, bone density, all that stuff. But you’re right that working night shifts creates additional challenges for recovery.

Your body has a natural internal clock that regulates when you sleep, your hormones, metabolism, and recovery. So constantly switching between night shift and a normal daytime schedule can disrupt that rhythm, making it harder to get quality sleep and recover the right way between workouts. My recommendation would be to prioritize getting seven to nine hours of total sleep whenever possible.

Keep your sleeping environment cool, dark, and quiet, and avoid caffeine for several hours before bedtime so you can get that seven to nine hours of sleep. And on your days off, schedule your hard workouts after you’ve had adequate sleep, rather than immediately after that 12-hour shift when your body’s so tired already. You may also need to adjust your training intensity and volume depending on how well you’ve recovered and how you feel.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

And again, maybe we should invite a sleep specialist to come join us for a conversation. Do you know what the recommended structure, the schedule, is for people like Melissa? They work three or four days on at nights. Is the recommendation to maintain the night schedule even when you’re not working nights? Is it healthier to be consistent, or is part of the challenge switching back and forth?

Srdjan Injac:
It’s the challenge of switching back and forth. It really is, and some people can adjust a lot easier than others. Some people don’t really struggle that much and they have energy, and usually those are younger people.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
But it’s challenging. It’s different for everyone.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
I mean, I have a lot of nurses that come here and they train at midnight or one o’clock in the morning.

Pete Wright:
Because that’s when they’re available, and that’s their daytime, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
That’s when their shift ends. Yeah, or before their shift.

They’ll come in, do the workout, and then go. And that’s what I would always recommend, before the shift.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
If it’s possible. That’s what a lot of people do, because that’s when they have all the energy. And then sometimes the workout will actually help them with energy and wake them up, and they can get through the shift easier than doing it after.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. Okay.

Well, I’m sorry. You’re right, Melissa. We were presuming a normal day, and you have a complex situation. Everybody working these night shifts, swing shifts, it’s hard. So we’ll talk more about that, and hopefully get somebody who will help us set the record straight.

Greg writes in and says, “Pete said his best sleep is the night after training. Srdjan said he can’t train in the evening because he’s already winding down. So which is it? Does training close to bed help sleep or hurt it?” Oh, another sleep question.

Srdjan Injac:
Yep. There you go.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
Well, we’re both right, because exercise affects everyone’s sleep differently. Regular exercise generally improves sleep quality, and that’s probably why you sleep so well after training.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
But a hard workout close to bedtime can increase your heart rate, body temperature, and alertness, making it harder for some people to fall asleep. That’s why I personally prefer to train earlier and not later in the evening. In the evening I’m already winding down, and I don’t want to get my body all fired up again.

And it doesn’t mean evening workouts are bad. Some people can train at night and they’re perfectly fine, and some prefer the morning.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So whatever works for you.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
I don’t know. For me, I get exhausted after so much heavy lifting, and I’m tired, and I eat, and I just want to crash and fall asleep sometimes. But in the morning it does give me energy. I just like doing it. I prefer mornings more than nights.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. I think, yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
After a long day of work, I get tired, so I don’t really have that strength that I can put in. Sometimes on the weekends, or when I’m not working, and I slept till 10 o’clock and I didn’t do anything, maybe in the evening I wouldn’t mind. I feel okay, feel fine. I don’t know.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. For me, maybe it’s just force of habit. I know exactly when I’m coming in. It’s on the calendar. It’s scheduled. It’s in the evening. I know the next thing I’m going to do is eat. And then it’s wind down and go to bed, and I’m all tired and gooey, and that’s perfect.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah, you have your routine and it works.

Pete Wright:
It’s perfect. God, I love routine.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
It’s important to have that routine. It helps you stay consistent.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So stick to your routine.

Pete Wright:
Yeah.

Srdjan Injac:
So you’re consistent. The people I see who are all over the place, usually those people are not consistent. I’ll see some of the schedules here, people that show up at different times, different days.

Pete Wright:
Oh, I couldn’t do it.

Srdjan Injac:
Sometimes they’ll be here, sometimes they’re not, and they’re not consistent with anything else either, and then they don’t really see the results. I’m like, well, you’ve got to find the routine and stick to it.

Pete Wright:
Yeah. All right. That is the end. Greg wraps up our listener questions extravaganza for this round. Thank you so much, everybody, for writing in. We’ve got more episodes coming, more fodder for more questions. Please check the show notes. There’s a link that says, “Hey, submit your question to the show.” And we’ll talk about them on our next bundle of questions.

We love the questions. Srdjan is fueled by these questions.

Srdjan Injac:
Yes.

Pete Wright:
He just gets bigger and stronger.

Srdjan Injac:
I love it.

Pete Wright:
He’s like the Hulk with listener questions.

Srdjan Injac:
Yeah.

Pete Wright:
And so we’re really excited to keep those questions coming. Thank you, everybody, for listening. And thank you for your time and your attention. Don’t forget to subscribe and share. This is how we grow stronger together. Thanks for listening to Build for Health.

We’ll catch you next week in the gym.

About the show

Hosted by Pete Wright and Srdjan Injac, Build for Health moves beyond gym culture to explore why muscle is critical for longevity, not just looks. Learn more about ELEV8 Fitness right here!

Visit the Show Page →