The Gunfighter • Member Bonus

The Gunfighter (1950) emerged from an unexpected path to production, with the story originally written for John Wayne, who declined due to a grudge against Columbia Pictures. The film ultimately landed at 20th Century Fox with Gregory Peck in the lead role, much to Wayne’s chagrin. Directed by Henry King, this “adult Western” marked a significant shift in the genre, focusing more on character psychology than action. Join us—Pete Wright and Andy Nelson—as we continue our Platinum Performances series, but for this member bonus episode, focusing on The 1950 Best Writing Oscar Race, with a conversation about The Gunfighter.

Pete and Andy explore how the film’s black-and-white cinematography enhances its themes, particularly in the contrast between interior and exterior scenes. They discuss how the saloon serves as a pressure cooker setting while the stark outdoor scenes create visual tension that mirrors the protagonist’s predicament.

The hosts delve deep into Jimmy Ringo’s character, examining how Gregory Peck portrays a man trapped by his own reputation. They discuss how the film subverts traditional Western tropes by focusing on the psychological toll of gunfighter fame rather than glorifying violence.

Pete and Andy examine how The Gunfighter influenced subsequent Westerns and discuss its potential upcoming remake with Ethan Hawke. They note the film’s unique position in the evolution of the Western genre, particularly its role in establishing more psychologically complex narratives.

The hosts agree that The Gunfighter remains remarkably relevant, particularly in its exploration of celebrity culture and the impossibility of escaping one’s past. They praise the film’s tight pacing, thoughtful character development, and Gregory Peck’s commanding performance. We have a great time talking about it, so check it out then tune in. The Next Reel—when the movie ends, our conversation begins!